GRE Quantitative Comparison: A Method That Handles (D)
A four-step method for GRE Quantitative Comparison: spot fixed comparisons, simplify both sides legally, plug in a planned set of numbers, and pick (D) only when it's earned.
By the Relvora team · Updated · 6 min read
Quantitative Comparison (QC) questions ask which of two quantities is greater. You rarely need either exact value. You need a routine that tells you whether the order is fixed or changes, so you neither pick (D) by reflex nor miss it.
In short: First check whether both quantities are fixed numbers. If they are, (D) is out. Then simplify the comparison, doing only what's legal: add or subtract the same thing on both sides, and multiply or divide only by something positive. If letters are left, plug in a planned set of values: a positive integer, 0, a negative, a fraction between 0 and 1, and a large number. Two allowed values that give different orders mean (D). Don't trust how a figure looks.
What are the four answers?
They never change, in this order:
| Answer | Meaning |
|---|---|
| (A) | Quantity A is greater. |
| (B) | Quantity B is greater. |
| (C) | The two quantities are equal. |
| (D) | The relationship can't be determined from the information given. |
Any information centered above the two quantities applies to both. A symbol that appears more than once means the same thing throughout the question.
The key idea is that (A), (B) and (C) each claim something about every allowed value. (A) means A is greater no matter which allowed values you use. (D) means the order depends on which values you pick.
Step 1: Is the comparison fixed?
If both quantities are specific numbers, such as 17 × 23 or "the area of a circle with radius 3", then each has one value. One of them is greater, or they're equal. The relationship can always be determined, so (D) can't be the answer. ETS gives the same advice: never pick the last choice when both values can be worked out by computation.
The same holds when the information pins every letter down. If x + 4 = 11, then x is 7, and the comparison is fixed.
Step 2: Simplify both sides legally
Write the comparison as A ? B, where ? stands for the unknown relationship. Then change both sides the same way, as you would with an inequality. Moves that keep the relationship:
- Add or subtract the same thing on both sides, whether it's a number or an expression.
- Multiply or divide by the same positive number.
- Square both sides only if you know both sides are nonnegative.
The move that breaks things: multiplying or dividing by a negative, or by a letter whose sign you don't know. A negative reverses the relationship. With an unknown sign, you can't tell whether it reversed. Subtract instead, and look at the sign of what's left.
Step 3: Plug in a planned set of numbers
If letters survive the simplification, test values the information allows. Don't pick the first number that comes to mind. Work through a set chosen to break patterns:
- A small positive integer, such as 2 or 3
- 0
- A negative, such as −1 or −2
- A fraction between 0 and 1, such as 1/2
- A large number, such as 100
Also try 1, and equal values if there are two letters. Skip any value the information rules out.
If two allowed values give different orders, stop: the answer is (D). If every test gives the same order, that's strong evidence but not proof. Confirm it by reasoning, as in Example 3 below.
Step 4: Treat figures with suspicion
Geometric figures aren't necessarily drawn to scale. A side that looks longer may not be. Work only from the labels, the text and geometry facts. ETS suggests redrawing the figure: keep what the information fixes, change what it doesn't, and see whether the order changes. Coordinate planes and data graphs are the exception, since those are drawn to scale.
Example 1: a fixed comparison
Quantity A: 17 × 23 Quantity B: 20² − 10
Both quantities are numbers, so (D) is out before you start.
17 and 23 sit 3 either side of 20, so 17 × 23 = (20 − 3)(20 + 3) = 20² − 9 = 391. Quantity B is 400 − 10 = 390.
Answer: (A). Spotting the structure saved a multiplication.
Example 2: the sign trap
y < 0 Quantity A: 3y − 4 Quantity B: 5y − 4
Add 4 to both sides: 3y ? 5y. Now subtract 3y from both sides: 0 ? 2y. Since y is negative, 2y is negative, so the left side is greater.
Answer: (A). Check with y = −1: Quantity A is −7 and Quantity B is −9, and −7 is greater.
The trap is dividing 3y ? 5y by y and getting 3 ? 5, which points to (B). Dividing by a negative reverses the relationship. Subtracting avoided the question entirely.
Example 3: a variable comparison that isn't (D)
Quantity A: (a + 5)² − 10a Quantity B: a² + 20
There's a letter and no information about it, which makes (D) tempting. Expand Quantity A: a² + 10a + 25 − 10a = a² + 25. Subtract a² from both sides: 25 ? 20.
Answer: (A). The order is the same for every value of a. A letter in the question doesn't make the relationship undetermined.
Example 4: plugging in finds (D)
k > 0 Quantity A: √k Quantity B: k/2
Run the planned set, skipping 0 and negatives, which the information rules out:
| k | √k | k/2 | Greater |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1/4 | 1/2 | 1/8 | A |
| 1 | 1 | 1/2 | A |
| 4 | 2 | 2 | Equal |
| 16 | 4 | 8 | B |
| 100 | 10 | 50 | B |
k = 1 makes A greater, and k = 16 makes B greater. Answer: (D).
Testing only k = 1/4 and 1 would have suggested (A). The large number broke the pattern.
Example 5: a constraint that fixes the answer
p is a prime number and 20 < p < 30. Quantity A: the remainder when p is divided by 6 Quantity B: 5
The information allows only two values: 23 and 29. When the allowed values are few, test all of them. 23 = 6 × 3 + 5 and 29 = 6 × 4 + 5, so the remainder is 5 both times.
Answer: (C). "p is unknown" isn't the same as "the relationship can't be determined."
Example 6: a figure that misleads
In triangle PQR, angle P = 50° and angle Q = 70°. In the figure, side QR is drawn longer than side PQ. Quantity A: QR Quantity B: PQ
Ignore the drawing. Angle R = 180° − 50° − 70° = 60°. In any triangle, the longer side is opposite the larger angle. QR is opposite angle P (50°), and PQ is opposite angle R (60°). So PQ is longer, whatever the figure shows.
Answer: (B).
Compare a version that gives only two sides: PQ = 6, QR = 9, and asks you to compare PR with 9. The third side of a triangle is between the difference and the sum of the other two, so 3 < PR < 15. PR could be 5 or 12, so that comparison is (D). The figure can't settle it either way.
What should you check after a QC mistake?
- Picked (D) on numbers? If both quantities were fixed, (D) was never possible.
- Divided by a letter? Check whether you knew its sign. Subtract next time.
- Tested only one kind of number? Run the full set: positive, 0, negative, fraction, large.
- Trusted the figure? Work from labels and geometry only.
- Picked the opposite quantity? ETS warns about swapping (A) and (B). Say "A is greater" to yourself before clicking.
For more on this format, read the Quantitative Comparison lesson. The signs and ranges behind many QC questions are covered in inequalities, absolute value and exponents and roots, and figure-based comparisons in triangles and circles. You can drill the format in timed sets on the QC practice page. For the other formats, see GRE Quant: what's tested and how it's scored.
GRE® is a registered trademark of ETS. Relvora is not affiliated with or endorsed by ETS.
Sources
Frequently asked questions
When is (D) the answer in GRE Quantitative Comparison?
When two values allowed by the information put the quantities in different orders, for example Quantity A greater for one value and Quantity B greater for another. If both quantities are fixed numbers, (D) is never right.
What numbers should you plug in on Quantitative Comparison?
Try a positive integer, 0, a negative number, a fraction between 0 and 1, and a large number, as long as the information allows them. These are the values most likely to change the order of the quantities.
Can you divide both quantities by a variable?
Only if you know the variable is positive. Dividing by a negative number reverses the comparison, and if you don't know the sign you can't tell whether it reversed.