GRE Quant lesson · QC strategy
GRE Quantitative Comparison strategy: test cases, simplify, and when to pick D
How to answer GRE Quantitative Comparison questions: plug in 0, 1, negatives and fractions, simplify both quantities, compare close numbers by structure, and pick D only when the allowed values disagree.
The core idea
A Quantitative Comparison question asks only which quantity is greater, so you rarely need exact values. Simplify both quantities the same way, then test the values the information allows, including 0, 1, negatives and fractions. If two allowed values order the quantities differently, the answer is D; if every allowed value gives the same order, it isn't.
Core ideas
Words used here
- Quantity A and Quantity B: the two things you compare. Information centred above them applies to both.
- Allowed value: a value of the letters that fits all the information given.
- Counterexample: an allowed value that breaks a pattern you expected.
- The four answers never change, and they always come in this order:
- (A) Quantity A is greater.
- (B) Quantity B is greater.
- (C) The two quantities are equal.
- (D) The relationship cannot be determined from the information given.
- Information above the quantities applies to both. A symbol that appears in both quantities means the same number in both.
- Two fixed numbers are never D. If neither quantity contains an unknown, one of A, B or C is right.
- D needs two allowed values that disagree. One value making A greater and another making B greater (or the two equal) proves D. One case alone proves nothing.
- Do the same thing to both sides. Add or subtract anything; multiply or divide only by a positive number. This keeps the comparison the same.
- The on-screen calculator can settle a comparison of two ugly numbers, but most QC questions are built so that structure (signs, sizes, factoring) settles them faster.
Try it. x is a number. Compare Quantity A, x, with Quantity B, x + 1.
Show the answer
Subtract x from both: Quantity A becomes 0 and Quantity B becomes 1. Whatever x is, Quantity B is greater (B).
Plug in 0, 1, negatives and fractions
When a quantity contains a letter, test the values the information allows that behave differently: 0, 1, a negative number, a fraction between 0 and 1, and a large number. Most traps are built around one of these.
Why it works. The order of two expressions can only change where they cross. Most crossings happen at 0 or 1, or between positives and negatives, so values on either side of those points find a change if there is one.
How to spot it: a letter with little information about it ("x ≠ 0", "x > 0", "x > y"), and two expressions that look like they have an obvious order.
GRE-level example. x > 0.
- Quantity A: x + 1/x
- Quantity B: 2
- Try x = 2: Quantity A is 2.5, greater than 2.
- Try x = 1: Quantity A is 1 + 1 = 2, equal to Quantity B.
- Two allowed values give different results, so the answer is (D).
Change the information to x < 0: then x and 1/x are both negative, so Quantity A is negative and Quantity B is greater (B).
More pairs worth knowing:
- x and −x with no information: D (x = 1 gives A; x = −1 gives B).
- x² + 1 and 2x: x² + 1 − 2x = (x − 1)², which is never negative. So Quantity A is greater except at x = 1, where they are equal. With no information that is D; with x ≠ 1 it is A.
- x > y, x² and y²: D, because 4 > 3 gives 16 > 9, but −3 > −4 gives 9 < 16.
- x > y > 0, 1/x and 1/y: B, because the larger positive number has the smaller reciprocal.
Trap: trying only x = 2 or x = 3. Positive whole numbers are the one kind of number the question writer expects you to try.
Check yourself. −1 < x < 0. Compare Quantity A, x², with Quantity B, −x.
Check your answer
Try x = −1/2: x² = 1/4 and −x = 1/2. For every x in the range, −x is a positive number below 1, and x² = (−x)² is smaller than it. Quantity B is greater (B).
Simplify both quantities
Treat the comparison like an inequality with an unknown sign between the quantities. Expand, cancel and collect the same way on both sides until what's left is easy to compare.
Why it works. Adding or subtracting the same expression from both quantities, or multiplying both by the same positive number, never changes which one is greater. So the simplified pair has the same answer as the original pair.
How to spot it: both quantities share a large piece (x², the same product, the same fraction) that hides a small difference.
GRE-level example. x is a number.
- Quantity A: (x + 2)²
- Quantity B: x² + 4
- Expand Quantity A: x² + 4x + 4.
- Subtract x² + 4 from both: Quantity A becomes 4x and Quantity B becomes 0.
- 4x is positive when x > 0 and negative when x < 0. With no information about x, the answer is (D).
With the information x > 0 the answer would be A, and with x < 0 it would be B.
Some pairs simplify to a fixed comparison. (x + 3)(x − 3) = x² − 9 is always 1 less than x² − 8, so that pair is B for every x, not D.
Trap: multiplying or dividing both quantities by a letter whose sign you don't know. Comparing x² with x by dividing both by x gives x against 1, which is right only for x > 0.
Check yourself. x > 0. Compare Quantity A, (x + 1)² − (x − 1)², with Quantity B, 3x.
Check your answer
(x + 1)² − (x − 1)² = (x² + 2x + 1) − (x² − 2x + 1) = 4x. Since x > 0, 4x > 3x, so Quantity A is greater (A).
Compare numbers that are close together
When the two quantities are close, rewrite one in terms of the other instead of estimating both. Products near each other, near-squares and halve-and-double pairs are the usual cases.
Why it works. Writing 48 × 51 as (49 − 1)(50 + 1) splits it into the other quantity plus a small leftover. Only the leftover decides the comparison, and it is easy to work out.
How to spot it: two products or expressions that round to the same number.
GRE-level example.
- Quantity A: 48 × 51
- Quantity B: 49 × 50
- Write 48 × 51 = (49 − 1)(50 + 1) = 49 × 50 + 49 − 50 − 1 = 49 × 50 − 2.
- So Quantity A is 2 less than Quantity B.
- Quantity B is greater (B). Check with the calculator if you like: 2,448 and 2,450.
Halving one factor and doubling the other keeps a product the same: 24 × 50 and 48 × 25 are both 1,200, so that pair is C.
Trap: rounding both to about 2,500 and choosing C, or choosing D because "it's too close to tell". Two fixed numbers are never D.
Check yourself. Compare Quantity A, 199 × 201, with Quantity B, 200² − 2.
Check your answer
199 × 201 = (200 − 1)(200 + 1) = 200² − 1, which is 1 more than 200² − 2. Quantity A is greater (A).
When the answer is D
Choose D only after you have two allowed values that order the quantities differently. Equations with two solutions, integer conditions and pairs of unknowns are where real D answers come from, and also where a fixed answer hides behind an unknown.
Why it works. D means "the information doesn't fix the order". One allowed value giving A and another giving B (or C) shows exactly that. If you can't find such a pair, look for a reason the order is always the same.
How to spot it: an equation like x² = 9, a condition that allows several integers, or two unknowns tied by one equation.
GRE-level example. x and y are positive integers, and xy = 12.
- Quantity A: x + y
- Quantity B: 7
- List every pair: 1 and 12, 2 and 6, 3 and 4 (in either order).
- The sums are 13, 8 and 7.
- 13 and 8 make Quantity A greater, but 7 makes the quantities equal. The answer is (D).
More cases:
- x² = 9, x against 2: x = 3 gives A and x = −3 gives B, so D. Add the information x < 0 and x = −3 only: B.
- n is an integer, n against n²: n² ≥ n for every integer, equal at n = 0 and n = 1 and smaller otherwise (n = 2 gives 2 and 4). Quantity A is never greater, but the answer is still D, because C and B both occur.
Trap: stopping after the first pair (2 and 6 gives 8 > 7, so "A") or the first root (x = 3). Find every case before you decide.
Check yourself. x and y are positive integers, and x + y = 7. Compare Quantity A, xy, with Quantity B, 10.
Check your answer
The pairs are 1 and 6, 2 and 5, 3 and 4, with products 6, 10 and 12. One product is less than 10, one equals it and one is greater, so the relationship cannot be determined (D).
Practice
Practice Quantitative Comparison in timed sets on the QC strategy practice page.
Common traps
Deciding after one kind of number
x² against x looks like "Quantity A is greater" for x = 3, but x = 1/2 makes Quantity B greater. Test a fraction, a negative, 0 and 1 whenever the information allows them.
Picking D for a comparison that is fixed
If both quantities are fixed numbers, or every allowed value gives the same order, the relationship can be determined. (x + 3)(x − 3) against x² − 8 is always B, even though x is unknown.
Calling quantities equal because they look alike
47 × 53 and 50² look alike but differ by 9. Equal only at one value (x² + 1 and 2x at x = 1) is not equal for every allowed value.
Picking the opposite quantity
After simplifying, check which side your larger expression came from. Writing the work as "A ? B" with the same order every time keeps the sides straight.
Forgetting the negative solution
x² = 9 means x = 3 or x = −3. Against 2, x = 3 is larger and x = −3 is smaller, so the answer is D unless the information says x > 0.
Squaring a sum term by term
(x + 2)² is x² + 4x + 4, not x² + 4. The middle term 4x is exactly what decides the comparison.
Assuming x > y keeps its order under squares or reciprocals
−3 > −4, but (−3)² = 9 < 16 = (−4)². And for x > y > 0, 1/x < 1/y. Check the signs before you square or flip.
Stopping after one pair of integers
If x and y are positive integers with xy = 12, x + y can be 13, 8 or 7. List every pair before you compare.
Changing the comparison while simplifying
You may add or subtract anything from both quantities, and multiply or divide both by a positive number. Multiplying by a negative number, or by a variable whose sign is unknown, can flip the comparison.
Estimating two close numbers too roughly
48 × 51 and 49 × 50 both round to about 2,500. The structure (or the exact values, 2,448 and 2,450) decides; a rough estimate doesn't.