Relvora Prep

GRE Quant lesson · Work rates

GRE work rate problems: combined work, pipes and drains

How to solve GRE work rate questions: add rates not times, handle a worker who stops midway, fill and drain tanks, and scale the number of machines.

The core idea

Work questions are about rates, not times: a worker who finishes a job in t hours does 1/t of the job per hour. Add rates for people working together, subtract rates that work against you, and convert back to time with time = work ÷ rate.

Core ideas

Words used here

  • Job: the whole task (one fence, one pool, one print run). We count it as 1.
  • Rate: how much work is done in one unit of time, such as 45 bottles per minute, or 1/6 of a job per hour.
  • Combined rate: the rate of two or more workers working together. It is the sum of their rates.
  • Net rate: what is left when one rate works against another, such as filling rate − draining rate.
  • Reciprocal: 1 divided by a number. The reciprocal of 6 is 1/6, and the reciprocal of 1/6 is 6. A time and a rate for one job are reciprocals.
  • Machine-hours: number of machines × number of hours. One machine running for 1 hour is 1 machine-hour.
  • Least common multiple (LCM): the smallest number that two numbers both divide into. The LCM of 4 and 6 is 12.
  • Rate = work ÷ time. If a job takes t hours, the rate is 1/t of the job per hour. A 6-hour job: 1/6 of the job each hour.
  • Work = rate × time, and time = work ÷ rate. Keep the time units the same as the rate's units.
  • Rates add when workers work together. Times never add.
  • Rates that work against each other subtract: net rate = filling rate − draining rate.
  • Shortcut for two workers: if they take a and b hours alone, together they take ab ÷ (a + b) hours. For 3 and 6 hours: 3 × 6 = 18 and 3 + 6 = 9, so 18 ÷ 9 = 2 hours.
Who Rate × Time = Work
One machine 45 bottles per minute 120 minutes 5,400 bottles
A painter who needs 6 hours 1/6 job per hour 2 hours 2/6 = 1/3 of the job

Try it. Pipe A fills a tank in 4 hours, and pipe B fills it in 12 hours. How long do they take together?

Show the answer
  1. Rates: A does 1/4 of the tank per hour, B does 1/12.
  2. Common denominator 12: 1/4 = 3/12. Together: 3/12 + 1/12 = 4/12 = 1/3 tank per hour.
  3. Time: 1 ÷ (1/3) = 3 hours. The shortcut agrees: (4 × 12) ÷ (4 + 12) = 48 ÷ 16 = 3.

Work = rate × time

For one worker or machine with a steady rate (the amount done in one unit of time), work = rate × time. Fill in the two numbers you know and solve for the third. First make the time units match the rate: a per-minute rate needs the time in minutes.

Why it works. A rate is the work done in one unit of time. t units of time do t times that much: work = rate × time. "Finishes a job in 6 hours" is the same as a rate of 1/6 job per hour.

How to spot it: one machine, one rate, and a question about output or time.

Example. A bottling machine fills 45 bottles per minute. How many bottles does it fill in 2 hours?

  1. The rate is per minute, so change the time to minutes: 1 hour = 60 minutes, so 2 hours = 2 × 60 = 120 minutes.
  2. Work = rate × time = 45 × 120. Split it: 45 × 100 = 4,500 and 45 × 20 = 900, so 4,500 + 900 = 5,400 bottles.

Trap: multiplying 45 by 2. That uses hours with a per-minute rate.

Edge cases.

  • Rates can be fractions or decimals: 2.5 crates per hour, or 3/5 of a crate in 12 minutes.
  • Match the units before multiplying (per minute with minutes).
  • Blocks of work. If 18 pages take 40 seconds, 540 pages are 540 ÷ 18 = 30 such blocks.

GRE-level example. A printer prints 18 pages every 40 seconds. At this rate, how many minutes does it take to print 540 pages?

  1. 540 pages are 540 ÷ 18 = 30 groups of 18 pages.
  2. Each group takes 40 seconds: 30 × 40 = 1,200 seconds.
  3. In minutes: 1,200 ÷ 60 = 20 minutes.
540 pages÷ 1830 groups of 18× 40 s1,200 seconds÷ 6020 minutes
Count blocks of work first, then change the time units at the end.

Check yourself. A worker packs 3/5 of a crate in 12 minutes. How long does she take to pack 4 crates?

Check your answer

Rate: (3/5) ÷ 12 = 1/20 crate per minute. Time for 4 crates: 4 ÷ (1/20) = 80 minutes.

Combined rate

Change each worker's time into a rate (the part of the job done per hour). Add the rates. Then turn the sum back into a time: time = 1 ÷ combined rate. The time together is always less than the fastest worker's time alone.

Why it works. Rates are amounts of work per hour, and the amounts done in the same hour add up. Times are not amounts of work, so they can't be added or averaged.

How to spot it: "working together", "at their respective constant rates, how long…".

Example. Printers A, B and C can each finish a print run alone in 4, 6 and 12 hours. How long do they take together?

  1. Rates: 1/4, 1/6 and 1/12 of the run per hour.
  2. Use the common denominator 12 (the LCM of 4, 6 and 12): 1/4 = 3/12 and 1/6 = 2/12.
  3. Combined rate: 3/12 + 2/12 + 1/12 = 6/12 = 1/2 run per hour.
  4. Time = 1 ÷ (1/2) = 2 hours. (Half a run each hour means a whole run in 2 hours.)
Hour 1ABC6/12Hours 1 and 2ABCABC12/12: done
In twelfths of the run: A, B and C add 3 + 2 + 1 = 6 each hour, so 2 hours finish all 12.

Trap: averaging the times: (4 + 6 + 12) ÷ 3 = 22 ÷ 3 ≈ 7.3 hours. That is slower than printer A alone, which can't be right.

For harder questions (L4–L5): only pairs are timed

Three pumps are timed only in pairs: the pairs fill a pool in 3, 4 and 6 hours.

  1. Pair rates: 1/3 + 1/4 + 1/6 = 4/12 + 3/12 + 2/12 = 9/12 = 3/4.
  2. Each pump is in two of the pairs, so this sum counts every pump twice. All three together: 3/4 ÷ 2 = 3/8 pool per hour.
  3. Time: 1 ÷ (3/8) = 8/3 hours = 2 2/3 hours = 2 hours 40 minutes (2/3 × 60 = 40).

See it. Each line shows how much of the job is done over time. Alone, A takes 3 hours and B takes 6. Together, the rates add (1/3 + 1/6 = 1/2 job per hour), so the blue line is steeper than both and reaches the whole job at 2 hours.

Work rates add

A does 1/3 of the job per hour; B does 1/6 per hour.

Together: 1/3 + 1/6 = 1/2 of the job per hour.

Time together = 1 ÷ (1/2) = 2 hours. That is less than the faster one alone (3 hours), as it must be.

Shortcut for two: ab ÷ (a + b) = 18 ÷ 9 = 2. Averaging the times (4.5) is the classic wrong answer.

Edge cases.

  • n identical workers take 1/n of the time one takes alone.
  • Finding one worker from the team. Subtract rates: together − known = unknown.
  • Sense check: two workers together take less time than the faster one alone, but at least half of that time.

GRE-level example. Working together, A and B finish a job in 6 hours. A alone takes 10 hours. How long does B take alone?

  1. Rates: together 1/6 job per hour; A 1/10.
  2. B's rate: 1/6 − 1/10 = 5/30 − 3/30 = 2/30 = 1/15 job per hour.
  3. B alone: 15 hours.
  4. Check with the shortcut: 10 × 15 ÷ (10 + 15) = 150 ÷ 25 = 6 ✓.

Check yourself. Two pipes fill a tank in 6 hours and 9 hours alone. How long do they take together?

Check your answer

6 × 9 ÷ (6 + 9) = 54 ÷ 15 = 3.6 hours = 3 hours 36 minutes.

One worker stops midway

Work in phases. First, find the combined rate (the rate of both workers together). Multiply it by the time they worked together to get the fraction of the job done. Subtract that from 1 to get the work left. Then divide the work left by the rate of whoever keeps working.

Why it works. Work adds across phases: the fractions of the job done in each phase must add up to 1 whole job. Each phase is its own rate × time.

How to spot it: "after x hours, one machine breaks down / leaves", "then the other finishes alone".

Example. Ana can paint a fence in 10 hours and Ben in 15 hours. They paint together for 3 hours, then Ben leaves. How many more hours does Ana need?

  1. Rates: Ana 1/10, Ben 1/15 fence per hour. Common denominator 30: 3/30 + 2/30 = 5/30 = 1/6 fence per hour together.
  2. In 3 hours together: 3 × 1/6 = 3/6 = 1/2 of the fence.
  3. Work left: 1 − 1/2 = 1/2 of the fence.
  4. Ana alone: (1/2) ÷ (1/10) = 1/2 × 10 = 5 hours.
The fenceAna: 3/10Ben: 1/5Ana alone: 1/2
Together for 3 hours they paint 3/10 + 1/5 = 1/2 of the fence. Ana does the other 1/2 alone in (1/2) ÷ (1/10) = 5 hours.

Trap: subtracting 3 from Ana's 10 hours (7). That ignores the work Ben did in the first 3 hours.

Edge cases.

  • A worker who joins late: phase 1 is one worker alone, phase 2 is both together.
  • An unknown phase length: call it t and write that the phases add to 1.
  • Read whose time is asked: the extra time, or the total time from the start.

GRE-level example. Pipe A fills a tank in 12 hours and pipe B in 8 hours. A is opened first; later B is opened too, and the tank is full 6 hours after A was opened. How long did A run alone?

  1. A runs for all 6 hours: 6 × 1/12 = 1/2 of the tank.
  2. B must fill the other half. At 1/8 tank per hour, that takes (1/2) ÷ (1/8) = 4 hours.
  3. So B ran for the last 4 hours, and A ran alone for 6 − 4 = 2 hours.
  4. Check: A alone 2 hours (1/6), then both 4 hours (4 × (1/12 + 1/8) = 4 × 5/24 = 5/6). Total 1/6 + 5/6 = 1 ✓.

Check yourself. A and B take 12 and 6 hours alone. They work together for 2 hours, then B leaves and A finishes. How long does the whole job take?

Check your answer

Together: 1/12 + 1/6 = 1/4 per hour, so 2 hours do 1/2. A finishes the other 1/2 at 1/12 per hour: 6 hours. Total: 2 + 6 = 8 hours.

Fill and drain

When one rate adds and another removes, the net rate (what is left after one works against the other) is their difference. Divide the work by the net rate. The time is longer than the filler alone would take.

Why it works. In one hour the pump adds 1/3 of a pool and the leak removes 1/12 of a pool. The net change in that hour is the difference, and it is the same every hour, so time = 1 ÷ net rate.

How to spot it: pipes and drains, a leak, people building while others take apart.

Example. A pump fills a pool in 3 hours, but a leak would empty the full pool in 12 hours. The pool starts empty and the leak is open. How long does filling take?

  1. Fill rate: 1/3 pool per hour. Leak rate: 1/12 pool per hour.
  2. Net rate: 1/3 − 1/12 = 4/12 − 1/12 = 3/12 = 1/4 pool per hour.
  3. Time = 1 ÷ (1/4) = 4 hours.
Pump, 1 hour+4/12Leak, 1 hour−1Net, 1 hour+3/12Net, 4 hours12/12: full
In twelfths of the pool: each hour the pump adds 4 and the leak takes 1, a net 3, so the pool is full after 4 hours.

Trap: adding the two rates (1/3 + 1/12 = 5/12 per hour). That makes the leak help fill the pool.

Try it. A tap fills a sink in 5 minutes. The open drain empties a full sink in 20 minutes. With both open, how long does the sink take to fill?

Show the answer
  1. Net rate: 1/5 − 1/20 = 4/20 − 1/20 = 3/20 sink per minute.
  2. Time: 1 ÷ (3/20) = 20/3 minutes = 6 2/3 minutes = 6 minutes 40 seconds (2/3 × 60 = 40).

See it. The gray lines are the pump alone (filling in 3 hours) and the leak alone (emptying a full pool in 12 hours). With both, the pool fills at the net rate, 1/4 pool per hour. Make the leak faster than the pump and the pool never fills.

Work rates add

Pump fills 1/3 of the tank per hour; Leak drains 1/12 per hour.

Net rate = 1/3 − 1/12 = 1/4 per hour.

Time to fill = 1 ÷ (1/4) = 4 hours.

Edge cases.

  • Drain as fast as the tap, or faster: the tank never fills.
  • Starting full and emptying: the net rate is negative; divide the amount in the tank by its size.
  • A drain opened later: split the time into phases.

GRE-level example. A tank is half full. Pipe A alone fills the tank in 6 hours, and drain B alone empties a full tank in 4 hours. If both are opened, how long until the tank is empty?

  1. Rates: A adds 1/6 tank per hour; B removes 1/4.
  2. Net: 1/6 − 1/4 = 2/12 − 3/12 = −1/12 tank per hour. The tank is emptying.
  3. Half a tank at 1/12 per hour: (1/2) ÷ (1/12) = 6 hours.

Check yourself. A tap fills a basin in 4 minutes and the open drain empties a full basin in 6 minutes. How long does the basin take to fill with both open?

Check your answer

Net: 1/4 − 1/6 = 1/12 basin per minute, so 12 minutes.

Scaling the number of machines

Find the output of one machine in one hour. Then every question about machines, hours and output follows from: output = machines × hours × output of one machine per hour.

Why it works. Identical machines each add the same rate, so total output = machines × hours × one machine's hourly output. A question fixes two of those three and asks for the third.

How to spot it: "n identical machines make k units in h hours; how many machines / hours / units…".

Example. 8 identical machines make 480 parts in 5 hours. How long would 12 such machines take to make 1,080 parts?

  1. Machine-hours used: 8 × 5 = 40.
  2. One machine in one hour: 480 ÷ 40 = 12 parts.
  3. 12 machines in one hour: 12 × 12 = 144 parts.
  4. Time: 1,080 ÷ 144 = 7.5 hours. (144 × 7 = 1,008, and the last 72 parts are half of 144, so 0.5 hour more.)

Trap: making the time longer because there are more machines. More machines make the same output faster.

Edge cases.

  • Whole machines. If the answer is 4.5 machines and the question asks how many are needed, round up to 5.
  • Machines added partway split the job into phases (see the example).
  • Different kinds of machines each need their own rate.

GRE-level example. 6 machines can fill an order in 8 hours. After 2 hours, 2 more machines join. How long does the whole order take?

  1. Total work: 6 × 8 = 48 machine-hours.
  2. In the first 2 hours: 6 × 2 = 12 machine-hours. Left: 36.
  3. With 8 machines: 36 ÷ 8 = 4.5 hours.
  4. Total time: 2 + 4.5 = 6.5 hours.
48 machine-hours6 × 2 = 128 × 4.5 = 36
The order is 6 × 8 = 48 machine-hours. The first 2 hours use 12; the 8 machines do the other 36 in 4.5 hours.

Check yourself. 5 workers build 3 walls in 6 days. How many walls do 8 workers build in 10 days?

Check your answer

One worker-day builds 3 ÷ (5 × 6) = 1/10 of a wall. 8 × 10 = 80 worker-days build 8 walls.

Work-rate comparisons on the GRE

The GRE gives you an on-screen calculator, so messy arithmetic is never the obstacle; the faster route is still to reason first and calculate only what the comparison needs.

  • Quantitative Comparison (QC). Bound the time together before computing it. Two workers together take less than the faster one alone and at least half of the faster one's time (exactly half when they work at the same rate).
  • Example. Working alone, Ana paints a fence in 6 hours, and Ben takes more than 6 hours. Quantity A: the hours they take together. Quantity B: 4.
    • Together they take 6b/(6 + b) hours when Ben takes b hours. With b = 8 that is 24/7 hours, less than 4; with b = 20 it is 60/13 hours, more than 4.
    • The answer is (D). Against 3 the answer would be (A): with Ben slower than Ana, the time together is always more than half of Ana's 6 hours.
  • Fill and drain. Subtract the rates, not the times: a pipe that fills in 4 hours against a drain that empties in 12 hours gains 1/4 − 1/12 = 1/6 of a tank per hour, so 6 hours.
  • Numeric Entry (NE). With one answer box, type a decimal such as 2.4. When the answer is a fraction like 7/3, the question gives two boxes, numerator and denominator, and the fraction doesn't need to be reduced.

How hard questions disguise it

For harder questions (L4–L5)

At L4 the rates hide in phases: someone joins late, leaves early or works at half speed. At L5, work questions combine with ratios ("A works twice as fast as B; together they take 6 hours; how long would B take alone?") and with picking numbers. There, letters replace the times, and you test a convenient job size. A job size equal to the least common multiple (LCM) of the times turns every rate into a whole number per hour.

Practice

Practice combined, midway and fill-drain questions in timed sets on the work rates practice page.

Common traps

  • Adding, subtracting or averaging times

    Two workers together must be faster than either alone, so any answer longer than the faster worker's time is wrong. Convert each time to a rate and add the rates; don't average them.

  • Mixing up a rate, a time and a fraction of the job

    A 6-hour job means a rate of 1/6 job per hour; 2 hours of work does 2/6 of it. Label every number as a rate, a time or a fraction of the job, and convert at the end.

  • Adding a rate that should be subtracted, or the reverse

    Rates that work together add, and a drain or leak subtracts. To get one worker's rate from a pair's rate, subtract the partner's rate.

  • Mishandling the work done before someone stops

    Split the job into phases. Find how much the team finished together, then finish the rest at the rate of whoever is still working.

  • Scaling workers, machines or hours the wrong way

    For a fixed job, machine-hours (or worker-days × hours per day) stay constant, so more machines means proportionally less time. Work through the output of one machine in one hour and every factor scales the right way.

  • Stopping at a total of machine-hours or machines

    Total machine-hours is a step: divide by the number of machines (or by the hours) to get what's asked, and subtract any machines already running.

  • Mixing minutes and hours

    If 12 bottles take 3 minutes, the rate is 12 ÷ 3 = 4 per minute, and 2 hours is 120 minutes. Put the rate and the time in the same units before multiplying.

  • Answering for the wrong machine or comparison

    Work questions produce each machine's time, the time together and the difference between them. Check which machine the question names, and remember that alone is always slower than together.

  • Combining pair rates wrong

    When pairs of pumps are timed, adding the three pair rates counts each pump twice, so halve the sum before inverting. All three together are faster than the fastest pair.

  • Work-rate comparisons: GRE traps

    Rates add, times don't; the time together, ab/(a + b), is below either time alone, and it grows toward the first worker's time as the partner slows down.