Two-Part Analysis and Multi-Source Reasoning: How to Approach Them
A method for GMAT Two-Part Analysis and Multi-Source Reasoning: solve each column alone, list the rules in every tab, and test must-be-true. 4 worked examples.
By the Relvora team · Updated · 8 min read
Two-Part Analysis and Multi-Source Reasoning are the two Data Insights types that look least like a normal math question. One gives you a grid with two answer columns. The other splits the facts across tabs. Each has a routine that keeps you from losing points to the format.
In short: In Two-Part Analysis, solve each column as its own question, remember that one option can answer both columns, and expect the wrong options to come from specific mistakes. In Multi-Source Reasoning, read every tab first, list the rules, apply them to the exact rows a question names, and only answer "must be true" when no allowed case breaks it.
How does Two-Part Analysis work?
You get a short problem and a list of options. Next to the options are two columns, each describing something to find. You pick one option per column. Credit is all-or-nothing: you need both columns right.
Three habits matter:
- Solve each column separately. Write down what each column asks for before you look at the options.
- The same option can answer both. Each column is its own question. If the same number fits both, pick it twice.
- Options are built from mistakes. A wrong option is often the result of a specific error, such as the wrong base or a forgotten fixed cost. Finding your answer in the list doesn't prove it's right. Check your pair against every condition in the problem.
Two-Part example 1: a fixed fee and a per-guest price
A caterer charges a fixed fee for each event plus a price for each guest. An event with 40 guests costs $1,300. An event with 70 guests costs $2,050. Select the fixed fee and the price per guest.
Options: $18.75, $25, $32.50, $300, $550, $750
Price per guest. The second event has 30 more guests and costs $2,050 − $1,300 = $750 more. The fixed fee is the same for both, so the extra $750 is all guest cost: $750 ÷ 30 = $25 per guest.
Fixed fee. The 40-guest event costs $1,300, and its guests cost 40 × $25 = $1,000. The fee is $1,300 − $1,000 = $300.
Check: $300 + 70 × $25 = $300 + $1,750 = $2,050. ✓
How the wrong options were built:
- $32.50 is $1,300 ÷ 40. It ignores the fixed fee.
- $18.75 is $750 ÷ 40. It divides by the wrong number of guests. That price leads to $550, from $1,300 − 40 × $18.75.
- $750 is the difference in cost, mistaken for the fee.
Notice that $18.75 and $550 make a pair. If you made that one mistake, you'd find both your answers in the list. That's why the final check against both events matters.
Two-Part example 2: when one option answers both columns
A shop sets each jacket's list price 25% above what the jacket cost the shop. Select the discount off the list price, as a percent, at which the shop would just break even. Then select the shop's profit, as a percent of cost, on a jacket sold at 4% off the list price.
Options: 20, 21, 25, 80, 96
You aren't given the cost, so pick one. Say the jacket costs $100. Then the list price is $125.
Break-even discount. To break even, the shop must sell at $100, which is $25 off $125. As a percent of the list price, that's 25 ÷ 125 = 20%.
Profit at 4% off. 4% of $125 is $5, so the sale price is $120. The profit is $20 on a $100 cost: 20%.
Both columns are 20. Pick it twice. The cost didn't matter: with any cost, 1.25 × 0.80 = 1 and 1.25 × 0.96 = 1.20.
How the wrong options were built:
- 25 assumes a 25% markup is undone by a 25% discount. It isn't: the discount comes off a bigger number. 1.25 × 0.75 = 0.9375, a loss of 6.25% of cost.
- 21 is 25 − 4, subtracting percents that have different bases.
- 80 is the break-even price as a percent of the list price. It forgets to subtract from 100.
- 96 is the sale price as a percent of the list price, not the profit.
If you'd crossed out 20 after using it in the first column, you'd have been forced into a wrong answer in the second.
How does Multi-Source Reasoning work?
You get two or more tabs of information: emails, notes, tables or charts. Several questions use the same tabs. Some are standard multiple choice. Others give you a few statements to judge, each with two choices such as yes/no.
The routine:
- Read every tab first. The fact that changes an answer is often in the tab you didn't open.
- List the rules. Write each one in a few words: "12-month commit → 10% off plan only." Rules hide in emails and footnotes, not just tables.
- Apply the rules to the exact rows. Find the row or item the question names. Don't work from a general impression of the table.
- Know must, could and cannot. A statement must be true if it holds in every case the tabs allow. It could be true if it holds in some. It cannot be true if it holds in none. When a question asks what must be true, "could be true" gets a no.
Both examples below use the same set of three tabs.
Tab 1: Plans (email from the manager of a coworking space) The Desk plan is $300 a month and includes 10 meeting-room hours. The Office plan is $900 a month and includes 30 meeting-room hours. Extra meeting-room hours cost $20 each. Teams that commit to 12 months get 10% off the monthly plan price. The discount doesn't apply to extra hours.
Tab 2: House rules Any team with more than 4 people must use the Office plan. Unused meeting-room hours don't carry over to the next month.
Tab 3: March usage
Team People Plan 12-month commitment Meeting-room hours used Alder 3 Desk Yes 14 Birch 6 Office No 25 Cedar 2 Desk No 10 Dune 5 Office Yes 41 Elm 4 Desk No 18
Your rule list:
- Desk: $300, 10 hours included. Office: $900, 30 hours included.
- Extra hours: $20 each.
- 12-month commitment: 10% off the plan price only.
- More than 4 people → Office plan.
- No carry-over of unused hours.
March bills, worked out once (you'll reuse them):
| Team | Plan price | Extra hours | Bill |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alder | $300 × 0.9 = $270 | 4 × $20 = $80 | $350 |
| Birch | $900 | 0 | $900 |
| Cedar | $300 | 0 | $300 |
| Dune | $900 × 0.9 = $810 | 11 × $20 = $220 | $1,030 |
| Elm | $300 | 8 × $20 = $160 | $460 |
Multi-Source example 1: applying a rule from another tab
In April, Elm grows to 5 people and uses 18 meeting-room hours. It doesn't commit to 12 months. What is Elm's April bill?
(A) $460 (B) $810 (C) $900 (D) $1,060 (E) $1,260
Elm now has 5 people. Tab 2 says a team with more than 4 people must use the Office plan. So Elm pays $900. The Office plan includes 30 hours, and Elm uses 18, so there are no extra hours. No commitment, so no discount.
Answer: (C) $900.
How the wrong options were built:
- (A) $460 keeps Elm on the Desk plan. It's what you get if you never open Tab 2.
- (B) $810 applies the 10% discount, which needs a 12-month commitment.
- (D) $1,060 charges extra hours above the Desk allowance of 10: $900 + 8 × $20.
- (E) $1,260 charges every hour as extra: $900 + 18 × $20.
Multi-Source example 2: must be true, or only could be?
For each statement, choose Yes if it must be true based on the information in the tabs. Otherwise, choose No.
- Dune's March bill was higher than Birch's.
- Exactly one team broke the house rule on team size in March.
- Alder will pay less than $350 in April.
- Yes. Dune paid $1,030 and Birch paid $900. Dune's discount saves it $90, but its 11 extra hours cost $220.
- No. The rule applies to teams with more than 4 people. Birch (6) and Dune (5) are on the Office plan. Elm has exactly 4 people, so the Desk plan is allowed. No team broke the rule, so "exactly one" is false.
- No. Alder's April bill depends on its April hours, which the tabs don't give. At 10 hours it would pay $270. At 14 hours it would pay $350. At 20 hours it would pay $470. The statement could be true, but it doesn't have to be.
All three parts must be right for credit. Statement 2 tests the boundary ("more than 4"). Statement 3 tests whether you can tell could be true from must be true.
What do the two types have in common?
Both reward checking over solving:
| Habit | Two-Part Analysis | Multi-Source Reasoning |
|---|---|---|
| Split the question | One column at a time | One statement at a time |
| Expect built-in mistakes | Options come from specific errors | Options and statements test a rule you skipped |
| Check against everything | Your pair against every condition | Your answer against every tab |
Relvora's GMAT Data Insights practice and lessons cover Two-Part Analysis and Multi-Source Reasoning. You can find them at GMAT Data Insights. For an overview of all five question types, see the Data Insights question types guide.
GMAT™ is a trademark of GMAC. Relvora is not affiliated with or endorsed by GMAC.
Sources
Frequently asked questions
Can the same answer be correct for both columns in Two-Part Analysis?
Yes. Each column is its own question, and one option can be the right answer to both. Don't rule an option out just because you've already picked it in the other column.
How should you start a Multi-Source Reasoning set?
Read every tab once before the first question and write down each rule in a few words. Then, for each question, apply those rules to the exact rows or items it names.
What does must be true mean in Multi-Source Reasoning?
It means the statement holds in every case the information allows. If it's only true in some cases, it could be true, and the answer to a must-be-true statement is no.