Relvora Prep

Data Sufficiency: The AD/BCE Method With Worked Examples

How to answer GMAT Data Sufficiency with the AD/BCE method: the five fixed answers, why a definite no is sufficient, breaking statements, and 4 worked examples.

By the Relvora team · Updated · 7 min read

Data Sufficiency asks a different question from normal math. You don't need the answer. You need to know whether you could get it. Once you see that, a fixed routine handles almost every question.

In short: Every Data Sufficiency question has the same five answers. Judge statement (1) alone, then statement (2) alone, and only then both together. A statement is sufficient when it gives exactly one answer: one value, or a definite yes, or a definite no. To prove a statement isn't sufficient, find two cases that fit it but give different answers.

What are the five Data Sufficiency answers?

They never change, so learn them before test day:

Answer Meaning
A Statement (1) alone is sufficient. Statement (2) alone is not.
B Statement (2) alone is sufficient. Statement (1) alone is not.
C Neither statement alone is sufficient, but the two together are.
D Each statement alone is sufficient.
E Even together, the statements are not sufficient.

Two rules sit behind every question:

  • The statements are always true. You never question them, and they never contradict each other.
  • "Sufficient" means one answer. For a value question, that's exactly one value. For a yes/no question, it's always yes or always no.

How does the AD/BCE method work?

Start with statement (1) alone, and ignore (2) completely.

  • (1) is sufficient: the answer is A or D. Now check (2) alone. Sufficient means D. Not sufficient means A.
  • (1) is not sufficient: the answer is B, C or E. Check (2) alone. Sufficient means B. If not, combine the two. Sufficient together means C. Otherwise it's E.

The method does two jobs. It stops you from reading (2) while you judge (1), which is an easy way to slip into a wrong answer. And it cuts the choices in half after one step, so even a guess on the second step is a better guess.

Why is a definite "no" sufficient?

Because the question asks whether you can answer, not whether the answer is yes. If a statement tells you the answer is always no, you know the answer. That's sufficient.

This trips people up because "no" feels like a failure. It isn't. The only failing outcome is "sometimes yes, sometimes no."

How do you break a statement?

To show a statement isn't sufficient, find two cases that fit it but give different answers. One pair is enough.

Is xy > 0? (1) x > y (2) x + y > 0

Try x = 2, y = 1. Both statements hold (2 > 1 and 2 + 1 > 0), and xy = 2, so the answer is yes.

Try x = 2, y = −1. Both statements still hold (2 > −1 and 2 + (−1) = 1 > 0), but xy = −2, so the answer is no.

Both cases fit both statements, so even together they aren't sufficient. Answer: (E).

Good cases to try: 0, a negative number, a fraction between 0 and 1, and equal values. These are the numbers that break the rules people assume.

Example 1: number properties (value question)

When the positive integer n is divided by 6, what is the remainder? (1) n is odd. (2) n is a multiple of 3.

Statement (1) alone. Odd numbers leave a remainder of 1, 3 or 5 when divided by 6. For example, 7 leaves 1 and 9 leaves 3. Not sufficient. That leaves B, C or E.

Statement (2) alone. Multiples of 3 leave 0 or 3. For example, 6 leaves 0 and 3 leaves 3. Not sufficient. That leaves C or E.

Together. n is an odd multiple of 3: 3, 9, 15, 21 and so on. Each leaves a remainder of 3. One value, so sufficient.

Answer: (C).

  • Why E tempts: each statement looks too vague to pin down a remainder. Combining them is the step people skip.
  • Why A or B tempts: one example (n = 9, say) gives remainder 3, and you stop there. One example never proves sufficiency.

Example 2: algebra (yes/no question)

Is x > y? (1) x − y = −3 (2) 2x + 1 < 2y − 5

Statement (1) alone. x − y = −3 means x is 3 less than y. So x > y is false, every time. A definite no is sufficient. That leaves A or D.

Statement (2) alone. Subtract 2y and 1 from both sides: 2x − 2y < −6. Divide by 2: x − y < −3. So x is more than 3 below y, and the answer is always no. Sufficient.

Answer: (D).

  • Why E tempts: both statements answer "no," and "no" feels like you didn't get an answer.
  • Why A tempts: (1) is an equation and (2) is an inequality, so (2) looks weaker. But an inequality is sufficient when every value it allows gives the same answer.

Example 3: word problem (value question)

Pens cost $2 each and notebooks cost $5 each. Maria spent exactly $31 on pens and notebooks. How many notebooks did she buy? (1) She bought an odd number of notebooks. (2) She bought more than 4 notebooks.

First, use what the question already gives you. The counts are whole numbers, and 2 × pens + 5 × notebooks = 31. The pens cost an even amount, so the notebooks must cost an odd amount, which means an odd number of notebooks. Seven notebooks would cost $35, too much. That leaves three possibilities:

Notebooks Pens Check
1 13 5 + 26 = 31
3 8 15 + 16 = 31
5 3 25 + 6 = 31

Statement (1) alone. All three possibilities already have an odd number of notebooks. The statement removes nothing. Not sufficient. That leaves B, C or E.

Statement (2) alone. Only 5 notebooks is more than 4. Sufficient.

Answer: (B).

  • Why E tempts: one equation with two unknowns looks unsolvable, and (2) is "only" an inequality. Whole-number counts change that.
  • Why D tempts: "odd" sounds like useful information. It is, but the question already told you.
  • Why C tempts: you combine the statements by habit, without checking (2) alone first.

Example 4: statistics (yes/no question)

The mean of five test scores is 80. Is the median of the five scores at least 80? (1) Three of the scores are 90. (2) The lowest score is 70.

The five scores sum to 5 × 80 = 400.

Statement (1) alone. The three 90s sum to 270, so the other two scores sum to 400 − 270 = 130. Both can't be above 90, since that would make their sum more than 180. So at least four scores are 90 or less, and at least three are 90 or more. The middle score is 90. Try two cases: 65, 65, 90, 90, 90 has median 90, and 30, 90, 90, 90, 100 also has median 90. The answer is always yes. Sufficient. That leaves A or D.

Statement (2) alone. Try 70, 70, 70, 95, 95. The sum is 400 and the median is 70, so no. Now try 70, 80, 80, 85, 85. The sum is 400 and the median is 80, so yes. Two cases, two answers. Not sufficient.

Answer: (A).

  • Why E tempts: in (1) you don't know two of the scores, so it feels like you can't place the median. You don't need them. You only need to know where the middle falls.
  • Why D tempts: a lowest score of 70 sounds like it caps how far the median can fall. It doesn't, because the other scores can bunch near 70.

What should you do after a Data Sufficiency mistake?

Write down which step failed, not just the letter you picked:

  • Read (2) while judging (1)? Cover statement (2) with your hand next time.
  • Stopped at one example? You needed a second case that broke the statement.
  • Treated a "no" as insufficient? Ask "is the answer the same every time?" instead.
  • Ignored the question's own facts? Whole numbers, positive values and "exactly" often do half the work, as in Example 3.

Relvora's GMAT Data Insights practice and lessons cover Data Sufficiency, with separate skills for number properties, algebra, inequalities, word problems and statistics. You can find them at GMAT Data Insights.

GMAT™ is a trademark of GMAC. Relvora is not affiliated with or endorsed by GMAC.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

What is the AD/BCE method in Data Sufficiency?

Judge statement (1) alone first. If it's sufficient, the answer is A or D, and statement (2) alone decides which. If it isn't, the answer is B, C or E: check (2) alone, then both together.

Is a definite no sufficient in Data Sufficiency?

Yes. A statement is sufficient when it gives one definite answer to the question. For a yes/no question, an answer of always no is just as sufficient as always yes.

How do you show a Data Sufficiency statement is not sufficient?

Find two cases that both fit the statement but give different answers to the question. One such pair proves the statement is not sufficient.

Keep reading