GRE Quant lesson · Solids (3-D)
GRE solids: volume, surface area, diagonals, cylinders and scaling
How to handle GRE questions about rectangular boxes, cubes and cylinders: volume, surface area, the diagonal through a box, scaling, filling tanks and pouring water, with worked examples and Quantitative Comparison traps.
The core idea
A box holds length × width × height and is wrapped by six faces in three equal pairs; a cylinder holds πr²h. The diagonal through a box is √(l² + w² + h²). When lengths scale by k, areas scale by k² and volumes by k³, and filling or pouring questions are volume ÷ rate or volume ÷ base area.
Core ideas
Words used here
- Rectangular box (rectangular solid): six rectangular faces meeting at right angles; its edges are the length l, width w and height h.
- Cube: a box whose edges are all equal (edge e).
- Volume: the space inside, in cubic units. Surface area: the total area of the faces, in square units.
- Right circular cylinder: two equal circular bases joined by a curved side, with the height perpendicular to the bases.
- Space diagonal: the segment through the inside of a box joining two opposite corners.
- Box: volume = lwh; surface area = 2(lw + wh + lh). Cube: volume = e³; surface area = 6e².
- Cylinder: volume = πr²h; the curved side has area 2πrh, and each base πr².
- Space diagonal of a box: √(l² + w² + h²); for a cube, e√3.
- Scaling: multiply every length by k and the areas grow by k², the volume by k³.
- Filling and pouring: time = volume ÷ rate; depth = volume ÷ base area.
- Figures are not drawn to scale: use the printed edges. The on-screen calculator is available, but these questions are usually faster with the formulas and π left in.
Try it. A box is 3 by 4 by 5. What are its volume and surface area?
Show the answer
Volume = 3 × 4 × 5 = 60. Surface area = 2(12 + 20 + 15) = 2 × 47 = 94.
Boxes and cubes: volume and surface area
Volume multiplies the three edges. Surface area adds the six faces, which come in three equal pairs.
Why it works. A box l by w by h can be filled with l × w unit cubes in each layer and h layers. Its faces are two l × w rectangles (top and bottom), two w × h and two l × h.
How to spot it: "rectangular box", "rectangular solid", "cube", "volume", "surface area".
Example. A box is 6 by 4 by 3. Find its volume and surface area.
- Volume = 6 × 4 × 3 = 72.
- Faces: 6 × 4 = 24, 4 × 3 = 12, 6 × 3 = 18. Surface area = 2(24 + 12 + 18) = 108.
A cube from its volume. A cube with volume 216 has edge 6 (6³ = 216), so its surface area is 6 × 36 = 216. At e = 6 the volume and the surface area are equal.
Trap: adding only three faces (54 above) or confusing surface area with volume.
Quantitative Comparison note. For a cube with edge e, compare the volume e³ with the surface area 6e². Dividing by e² > 0 leaves e against 6. If e > 6, the volume is greater; if 4 < e < 8, the answer is (D).
GRE-level example. A box has integer edges and volume 12. Which of 32, 36, 40 could be its surface area? Indicate all such areas.
- The boxes: 1 × 1 × 12, 1 × 2 × 6, 1 × 3 × 4, 2 × 2 × 3.
- Their surface areas: 2(1 + 12 + 12) = 50, 2(2 + 12 + 6) = 40, 2(3 + 12 + 4) = 38, 2(4 + 6 + 6) = 32.
- The answer is 32 and 40; 36 is not possible.
Check yourself. A box with a square base of side 5 has volume 150. What is its height?
Check your answer
150 ÷ (5 × 5) = 6.
Cylinders
A cylinder's volume is the base area times the height: πr²h.
Why it works. Like a stack of identical circular discs, a cylinder holds (area of one base) × (height). The curved side unrolls into a rectangle 2πr long and h high, so its area is 2πrh.
How to spot it: "right circular cylinder", a can, a pipe, a cylindrical tank.
Example. A cylinder has a diameter of 8 and a height of 5. What is its volume?
- The radius is 8 ÷ 2 = 4.
- Volume = π × 4² × 5 = 80π.
Trap: using the diameter: π × 8² × 5 = 320π, four times too big.
Quantitative Comparison note. Cylinder P has radius r and height h; cylinder Q has radius h and height r. Their volumes are πr²h and πh²r, which differ by πrh(r − h). So the one with the larger radius holds more. With r = 3 and h = 5, Q's volume (75π) beats P's (45π). If you only know that r and h are positive, the answer is (D).
GRE-level example. A cylinder fits exactly inside a box with a square base of side 6 and height 10 (it touches all four sides). What is the volume of the space inside the box and outside the cylinder?
- The cylinder's diameter is 6, so r = 3, and its height is 10. Its volume is π × 9 × 10 = 90π.
- The box holds 6 × 6 × 10 = 360.
- The space left is 360 − 90π, about 77.3.
Check yourself. A cylinder has volume 72π and radius 3. What is its height?
Check your answer
π × 9 × h = 72π, so h = 8.
The diagonal through a box
The diagonal from one corner of a box to the opposite corner is √(l² + w² + h²).
Why it works. Use the Pythagorean theorem twice. Across the bottom face, the diagonal is √(l² + w²). That diagonal and the vertical edge h are the legs of a right triangle whose hypotenuse is the space diagonal: √(l² + w² + h²).
How to spot it: "the distance between opposite vertices", "the longest rod that fits in the box", or a dashed segment through a box.
Example. A box is 2 by 3 by 6. What is its space diagonal?
- √(2² + 3² + 6²) = √(4 + 9 + 36) = √49 = 7.
Trap: stopping at a face diagonal (√13 for the 2 × 3 face) or adding the edges (11).
GRE-level example. A cube has a total surface area of 150. What is the length of the diagonal joining two opposite vertices?
- Each face has area 150 ÷ 6 = 25, so the edge is 5.
- The diagonal is √(5² + 5² + 5²) = √75 = 5√3.
Check yourself. What is the space diagonal of a box 4 by 4 by 7?
Check your answer
√(16 + 16 + 49) = √81 = 9.
Scaling solids
Multiply every length of a solid by k, and its surface area is multiplied by k² and its volume by k³. For a cylinder, the volume factor is (radius factor)² × (height factor).
Why it works. Volume multiplies three lengths, so each of the three picks up a factor of k. In πr²h the radius appears twice and the height once.
How to spot it: "doubled", "tripled", "half the radius", "how many times the volume".
Example. The radius of cylinder Q is twice the radius of cylinder P, and its height is half of P's. How do their volumes compare?
- Volume factor = 2² × 1/2 = 2.
- Q holds twice as much as P.
A cube whose edges are tripled has 3³ = 27 times the volume and 3² = 9 times the surface area.
Trap: multiplying the factors without squaring the radius factor (2 × 1/2 = 1 above).
Quantitative Comparison note. If the radius of Q is 3 times the radius of P and the height of Q is less than the height of P, the volume of Q is less than 9 times P's. Compare with 9 times P's volume: (B). Compare with 4 times P's volume: Q could hold more or less, so (D).
GRE-level example. The edges of a box are each multiplied by 1.5. Its new volume is 270. What was the original volume?
- The volume factor is 1.5³ = 3.375.
- Original volume = 270 ÷ 3.375 = 80.
Check yourself. A cylinder's radius is halved and its height is multiplied by 4. What happens to its volume?
Check your answer
(1/2)² × 4 = 1: the volume is unchanged.
Filling and pouring
Time to fill = volume still needed ÷ rate. Water poured into another container keeps its volume, so its depth there is volume ÷ base area.
Why it works. A constant rate means equal volumes in equal times. The water in a box or cylinder is itself a box or cylinder with the container's base, so its volume is base area × depth.
How to spot it: "pumped in at a rate of", "how long to fill", "poured into", "how deep is the water".
Example. A tank 10 feet long, 6 feet wide and 4 feet deep contains water 1 foot deep. Water is pumped in at 12 cubic feet per minute. How long until the tank is full?
- Water still needed: 10 × 6 × (4 − 1) = 180 cubic feet.
- Time = 180 ÷ 12 = 15 minutes.
Trap: filling the whole tank (240 cubic feet, 20 minutes) when it already holds water.
Numeric Entry note. Depths and times may be fractions or decimals: type a terminating decimal such as 7.5, or use the two fraction boxes for an answer like 16/9.
GRE-level example. Cylinder P, with radius 4, holds water 9 centimeters deep. All of it is poured into empty cylinder Q, with radius 6. How deep is the water in Q?
- Volume = π × 4² × 9 = 144π.
- Q's base is π × 6² = 36π, so the depth is 144π ÷ 36π = 4 centimeters.
The π cancels: depth = r₁²h₁ ÷ r₂² = 16 × 9 ÷ 36.
Check yourself. Water 6 inches deep in an 8 × 5 inch box is poured into an empty 12 × 10 inch box. How deep is it?
Check your answer
8 × 5 × 6 = 240 cubic inches, spread over 120 square inches: 2 inches.
Common traps
Counting only some of the faces
A box has six faces, in three equal pairs: surface area = 2(lw + wh + lh). Adding just lw + wh + lh gives half of it, and volume is not surface area.
Using a face diagonal for the diagonal through the box
The diagonal from one corner to the opposite corner needs all three edges: √(l² + w² + h²). It is not l + w + h, and not the diagonal of one face.
Using the diameter, or forgetting to square the radius
A cylinder's volume is πr²h. Halve a diameter first; πd²h is four times too big, and 2πrh is the area of the curved side, not the volume.
Scaling a volume like a length
Multiply every length by k and the volume is multiplied by k³; double a cylinder's radius and its volume is multiplied by 4. Square (or cube) the factor before you compare.
Filling the wrong amount, or dividing the wrong way
Time = volume still to fill ÷ rate. Count only the water to be added, and divide the volume by the rate, not the rate by the volume.
Deciding a comparison from one value
e³ and 6e² swap order at e = 6, and two cylinders with radius and height swapped compare like r and h. If the information allows values on both sides, the answer is (D).
Stopping early on a select-all question
On "Indicate all such" questions, list every case (for example every box with the given volume) and test every choice.