GMAT Data Insights lesson · Two-Part: equations
GMAT Two-Part Analysis: equations and conditions
How to answer GMAT Two-Part Analysis questions on equations: one list of options, two columns, and the traps that cost points.
The core idea
A Two-Part Analysis question gives one list of options and two columns. Each column asks for a different value, both must be right, and the same option can answer both. Solve for each value on its own, then find it in the list.
Core ideas
A Two-Part Analysis question has a short scenario, one list of options and two columns. You pick one option in each column, and both picks must be right. The same option can be the answer to both columns.
Why it works. The two columns are two separate questions about the same scenario, so solve each one on its own. The list is built from values that common mistakes produce, so finish the work before you look at the options.
Two unknowns
Why it works. Adding the two equations cancels y, and subtracting them cancels x, so each column's value comes out of one step.
How to spot it: two conditions on two numbers, and one column for each number.
Example. The numbers x and y satisfy both x + y = 30 and x − y = 8. Select x and y.
- Add the equations: 2x = 30 + 8 = 38, so x = 19.
- Subtract them: 2y = 30 − 8 = 22, so y = 11.
- Check: 19 + 11 = 30 and 19 − 11 = 8.
Trap: picking 15, the average of x and y, or 38, which is 2x before halving. Both are in the list on purpose.
Try it. x + y = 44 and x − y = 6. What are x and y?
Show the answer
2x = 50, so x = 25; 2y = 38, so y = 19.
Values that meet conditions
Why it works. The conditions on x alone leave only a few candidates. The equation turns each candidate into a value of y, and y's own condition rules out all but one. Testing that short list is faster and safer than testing every option, and it proves the answer is the only one.
How to spot it: an equation that links x and y, plus conditions on each of them: a bound, a multiple, odd or even, prime, a perfect square.
Example. The positive integers x and y satisfy x + y = 43. Also, x is less than 20, x is a multiple of 4, and y is a prime number. Select x and y.
- List the values the conditions on x allow: 4, 8, 12 and 16.
- Turn each one into y = 43 − x: 39, 35, 31 and 27.
- Test y: 39 = 3 × 13, 35 = 5 × 7 and 27 = 3 × 9 aren't prime, but 31 is. So x = 12 and y = 31.
Trap: values that pass all but one condition. x = 24 is a multiple of 4 and gives y = 19, a prime, but it isn't less than 20. x = 2 gives y = 41, a prime, but it isn't a multiple of 4. And 39 looks prime but is 3 × 13.
Try it. The positive integers x and y satisfy x + y = 37. Also, x is less than 30, x is a multiple of 7, and y is a prime number. What are x and y?
Show the answer
x can be 7, 14, 21 or 28, which give y = 30, 23, 16 or 9. Only 23 is prime, so x = 14 and y = 23.
Expressions from the givens
Why it works. (x + y)² = x² + 2xy + y² and (x − y)² = x² − 2xy + y². These two identities tie together the sum, the difference, the product xy and the sum of squares x² + y²: know two of them and you can find the others without finding x and y. One more: x² − y² = (x + y)(x − y).
How to spot it: the columns ask for expressions such as x² + y², (x − y)² or xy, not for x and y themselves.
Example. The numbers x and y satisfy x + y = 11 and xy = 18. Select the value of x² + y² and the value of (x − y)².
- (x + y)² = 11² = 121, and that is x² + y² + 2xy.
- So x² + y² = 121 − 2 × 18 = 85.
- (x − y)² = x² + y² − 2xy = 85 − 36 = 49. (Or in one step: (x + y)² − 4xy = 121 − 72 = 49.)
Trap: 121 keeps the 2xy in, 103 (121 − 18) takes off xy instead of 2xy, and 157 (121 + 36) adds 2xy instead of subtracting it. In the (x − y)² column, 85 is the other column's answer.
Try it. The numbers x and y satisfy x − y = 3 and xy = 10. What are x² + y² and (x + y)²?
Show the answer
x² + y² = (x − y)² + 2xy = 9 + 20 = 29, and (x + y)² = (x − y)² + 4xy = 9 + 40 = 49.
Greatest possible values
Why it works. To make x as large as possible, give y the smallest value it is allowed; whatever is left caps x. x must be a whole number, so take the largest one under the cap. When an equation ties x to y, y must come out a whole number too, so count down from the cap until it does.
How to spot it: "greatest possible" or "least possible" in the columns, integers, and an equation or inequality with bounds on x and y.
Example. x and y are positive integers, and 4x + 7y = 100. Select the greatest possible x and the greatest possible y.
- y is at least 1, so 4x ≤ 100 − 7 = 93 and x ≤ 23.
- Count down until 100 − 4x is a multiple of 7: 23 gives 8, 22 gives 12, 21 gives 16, 20 gives 20, 19 gives 24, 18 gives 28. So x = 18, with y = 4.
- x is at least 1, so 7y ≤ 96 and y ≤ 13. 100 − 7y must be a multiple of 4: 13 gives 9, 12 gives 16. So y = 12, with x = 4.
Trap: 23 for x (y = 8 ÷ 7, not a whole number), 25 for x (y = 0, not positive) and 13 for y (x = 9 ÷ 4). The least x, 4, is in the list too: it's the partner of the greatest y.
Try it. x and y are integers with x ≥ 2, y > 3 and 5x + 4y ≤ 80. What are the greatest possible x and the greatest possible y?
Show the answer
The least y is 4 (y > 3 rules out 3), so 5x ≤ 80 − 16 = 64 and x ≤ 12.8: x = 12. The least x is 2, so 4y ≤ 80 − 10 = 70 and y ≤ 17.5: y = 17. Using y = 3 would give x = 13, but y must be greater than 3.
Pairs that work together
Why it works. When a condition uses both letters (an equation such as xy = 48, or x < y), a value can't be right or wrong on its own: only a pair can be tested. Start from the equation, which allows only a few pairs from the list, then strike out each pair that breaks a condition. Exactly one pair survives.
How to spot it: conditions on x alone and on y alone, plus one or two conditions that mention both, and several options that pass their own condition.
Example. The options are 1, 4, 6, 8, 12 and 48. x and y are positive integers that meet all four of these conditions: x is even; y is a multiple of 3; xy = 48; x is less than y.
- Pairs from the list with xy = 48: (1, 48), (4, 12), (6, 8), (8, 6), (12, 4) and (48, 1).
- x even strikes out (1, 48). y a multiple of 3 strikes out (6, 8), (12, 4) and (48, 1).
- That leaves (4, 12) and (8, 6), and x < y strikes out (8, 6). So x = 4 and y = 12.
Trap: 8 for x and 6 for y. Each passes its own condition and 8 × 6 = 48, but x isn't less than y. And 12 for x: it's even, but its partner 4 isn't a multiple of 3.
Try it. The options are 1, 2, 7, 13, 18 and 19. x and y meet all four of these conditions: x is a prime number; y is a prime number; x + y = 20; x is less than y. What are x and y?
Show the answer
Pairs with x + y = 20: (1, 19), (2, 18), (7, 13), (13, 7), (18, 2) and (19, 1). Both prime: (7, 13) and (13, 7). x < y leaves (7, 13), so x = 7 and y = 13.
Practice
Practice Two-Part Analysis on the practice page.
Common traps
Putting a value in the wrong column
The list holds both answers, so the other column's value is always there. Name what each column asks for before you pick.
Stopping at a sum, a difference or half of something
The options include the values you pass on the way: x + y, x − y, 2x, the average. Finish the last step before you look at the list.
Checking only some of the conditions
Most options meet some of the conditions. Test every one, and remember that a value for x also fixes y, so y's conditions are part of x's test.
Taking 1, or an odd composite, for a prime
1 is not prime, and odd numbers such as 27, 39 and 91 aren't either. Try the small primes 3, 7 and 13 as factors before you call a number prime.
Ignoring the condition that links x and y
A condition like x < y can only be tested on a pair. A value that passes its own condition can still be wrong because of its partner.
Expanding a square wrongly
(x + y)² = x² + 2xy + y² and (x − y)² = x² − 2xy + y². The 2xy term is the one that gets dropped, doubled, halved or given the wrong sign.
Getting a boundary wrong
'Greater than 3' rules 3 out, 'positive' rules 0 out, and x ≤ 12.8 means x is at most 12, not 13.
Stopping short of the true extreme
A value that works isn't necessarily the greatest. Find the cap first, then count down from it until every condition holds, including that the other unknown is a whole number.