GMAT Data Insights lesson · Multi-Source: rules and data
GMAT Multi-Source Reasoning: rules applied to data
GMAT Multi-Source Reasoning when one tab sets the rules and another holds the data: two rules at once, tiered fees, exceptions, must or could be true.
The core idea
In Multi-Source Reasoning the information is split across tabs. One tab often states rules (prices, limits, eligibility) and another holds the data; a third tab can change a rule for one group. Read every tab first, then apply each rule to exactly the rows a statement names.
Core ideas
A Multi-Source Reasoning question comes with two or three tabs: text (an email, a policy, a report), a table or a chart. The statements need information from more than one tab, so read every tab before you start.
Why it works. Each tab holds part of the story. A rule from one tab, applied to data from another, gives facts that neither tab states alone.
Applying a rule
Example. Pricing tab: every parcel costs $8; each parcel heavier than 5 kg costs an extra $3; an order of 12 or more parcels gets 10% off its whole charge. Orders tab: Calder sent 12 parcels, 4 of them over 5 kg.
- Base charge: 12 × $8 = $96.
- Surcharges: 4 × $3 = $12, so $108 before the discount.
- 12 parcels is "12 or more", so the discount applies: $108 × 0.9 = $97.20.
Trap: forgetting the discount ($108) or the surcharges ($86.40). Both are tempting because each uses most of the rules.
Try it. With the same pricing, Dunmore sent 11 parcels, 2 over 5 kg. What does Dunmore pay?
Show the answer
11 × $8 + 2 × $3 = $94. 11 parcels is below 12, so there's no discount: $94.
Two rules at once
Why it works. "Only if both of these are true" joins two tests with and. A row is in only when it passes each test, so the rows that pass both are where the two lists overlap. Test each rule on its own, then keep the overlap.
How to spot it: the rules tab says "only if both", "must meet both conditions" or "and"; statements ask whether a named row qualifies, whether every (or no) row in a group qualifies, or how many qualify.
Example. Policy tab: a staff member may take a paid sabbatical only if both of these are true: (1) they have at least 6 years of service; (2) they have taken no more than 4 sick days in the last 12 months.
| Employee | Department | Years of service | Sick days |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arden | Sales | 7 | 2 |
| Bexley | Sales | 6 | 5 |
| Calder | Finance | 9 | 4 |
| Dunmore | Finance | 5 | 1 |
| Elstow | Sales | 6 | 4 |
| Fenwick | Design | 12 | 7 |
- Rule 1, "at least 6": Arden, Bexley, Calder, Elstow and Fenwick pass (6 counts). Dunmore (5) fails.
- Rule 2, "no more than 4": Arden, Calder, Dunmore and Elstow pass (4 counts). Bexley (5) and Fenwick (7) fail.
- Both: Arden, Calder and Elstow, so exactly 3 qualify. "Every employee in Sales qualifies" is false: Bexley has 5 sick days.
Trap: counting the rows that pass one rule. Rule 1 alone gives 5, and counting anyone who passes either rule gives all 6. Both feel right because every row you count does pass a rule.
Try it. Keep the table, but suppose rule 2 said "fewer than 4 sick days". How many employees would qualify?
Show the answer
Rule 2 now leaves out exactly 4, so Calder and Elstow (4 sick days each) fail it. Of the rows that pass rule 1, only Arden (2 sick days) passes the new rule 2: 1 employee.
Computing with a rule
Why it works. A fee schedule is a formula in words. Each clause covers a part of the amount: one rate up to a point, another rate after it, a flat fee on top, a cap on the total. Write the formula, put the row's numbers in, and every clause is used exactly once.
How to spot it: a rate that changes ("for each of the first 6 weeks ... from week 7 on"), a percent of the amount above a target, an extra for meeting a condition, a fee taken off, or a most-anyone-can-get cap.
Example. Fee schedule: storage costs $4 per pallet per week for each of the first 6 weeks; from week 7 on, it costs $6 per pallet per week; each delivery carries a $25 handling fee. Clients tab: Garrow stored 12 pallets for 9 weeks, with 2 deliveries. Is Garrow's bill more than $500?
- Weeks 1 to 6: 12 × $4 × 6 = $288.
- Weeks 7 to 9 (3 weeks): 12 × $6 × 3 = $216.
- Handling: 2 × $25 = $50.
- Bill: $288 + $216 + $50 = $554, so yes, more than $500.
Trap: charging all 9 weeks at $4 gives $482, under $500, so the answer flips. Charging all 9 weeks at $6 gives $698; leaving out the handling fees gives $504. Each uses most of the schedule, so each looks finished.
Try it. A bonus plan pays 5% of sales above $40,000, plus $500 for signing 3 or more new clients; no bonus can be more than $2,500. Kirby sold $78,000 and signed 3 new clients. Lowell sold $95,000 and signed 4. What does each get?
Show the answer
Kirby: 5% × ($78,000 − $40,000) = $1,900, plus $500 (3 counts as "3 or more") = $2,400, under the cap. Lowell: 5% × ($95,000 − $40,000) = $2,750, plus $500 = $3,250, capped at $2,500. Taking 5% of all of Kirby's $78,000 would give $3,900 plus $500, which the cap would also cut to $2,500.
An exception in another tab
Why it works. An email or memo that changes "one rule for one group" leaves everything else as it was. So each row needs one question first: is it in the group the email names? If so, use the new rule; if not, the old one.
How to spot it: three tabs, one of them a message ("From this week, in the North region only ...", "staff in Operations can ...", "Prices at the other branches are unchanged").
Example. Delivery policy: delivery is free on orders of $75 or more; orders under $75 pay a delivery charge of $6. Email: from this week, free delivery for orders in the North region starts at $90 instead of $75.
| Customer | Region | Order value ($) |
|---|---|---|
| Arden | North | 80 |
| Bexley | South | 80 |
| Calder | North | 95 |
| Dunmore | South | 70 |
- Arden is in North, so the $90 point applies: $80 is under $90, so Arden pays the $6 charge.
- Bexley is in South, so the old $75 point applies: $80 is enough, so delivery is free.
- Calder (North, $95) is free; Dunmore (South, $70) pays. So 2 of the 4 orders pay the charge.
Trap: missing the email makes Arden's delivery free; applying the email everywhere makes Bexley pay. Both give "1 of 4 orders pays" or "3 of 4", near the right count, which is why they're tempting.
Try it. Leave policy: up to 5 unused days carry over to next year; the rest are lost. Email from HR: staff in Operations can carry over up to 8 unused days this year. Jarrow (Operations) and Kirby (Sales) each have 7 unused days. How many days does each carry over?
Show the answer
Jarrow is in Operations, so the limit is 8: Jarrow carries over all 7 days. Kirby is in Sales, where the limit is still 5: Kirby carries over 5 and loses 2.
Must, could or cannot be true
Why it works. When the table doesn't say where each row went, the rules only narrow it down. For every row, start with all the places and strike out each one a rule forbids. What's left is the full list of possibilities: one place left means it must be true; a place still on the list could be true; a struck-out place cannot be true.
How to spot it: "exactly one of three warehouses / panels / rooms", rules with "every", "no", "only" or "never", and statements or a question with "must", "could" or "cannot".
Example. Each order is packed at exactly one warehouse: North, South or East, and the three rules are the only limits. Rule 1: every order worth more than $800 is packed at South. Rule 2: no order with more than 12 items is packed at North. Rule 3: fragile orders are never packed at East.
| Customer | Order value ($) | Items | Fragile |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arden | 950 | 5 | No |
| Bexley | 600 | 14 | Yes |
| Calder | 600 | 14 | No |
| Dunmore | 800 | 3 | Yes |
- Arden: $950 is more than $800, so Rule 1 puts it at South. Must be South.
- Bexley: Rule 1 doesn't apply; Rule 2 strikes North (14 items) and Rule 3 strikes East (fragile). Only South is left, so it must be South, even though Rule 1 doesn't apply.
- Calder: Rule 2 strikes North; South or East are left. "Calder's order must be packed at South" is false; it only could be.
- Dunmore: $800 is not more than $800, so Rule 1 doesn't apply; Rule 3 strikes East. North or South are left, so "Dunmore's order could be packed at South" is true.
Trap: reading Rule 1 backwards. It says big orders go to South; it doesn't say only big orders do, so Dunmore and Calder can still go to South. The other classic slips: calling Calder's South "must" (it's only "could"), and skipping Rule 2 or 3 for Bexley, which leaves it looking undecided.
Try it. Same rules. Elstow's order is worth $1,000, has 15 items and is fragile; Fenwick's is worth $700, has 8 items and isn't fragile. Is "Elstow's order could be packed at North" true? Must, could or cannot: "Fenwick's order is not packed at South"?
Show the answer
Elstow: $1,000 is more than $800, so Rule 1 puts it at South: it cannot be at North, so the statement is false. Fenwick: no rule applies (Rule 1 needs more than $800, Rule 2 more than 12 items, Rule 3 a fragile order), so any warehouse is possible. "Not at South" could be true, but it isn't forced.
Practice
Practice Multi-Source Reasoning on the practice page.
Common traps
Leaving out a rule from another tab
A charge, an extra or a limit stated in the text tab applies to the table's rows too. List every rule before you compute, and tick each one off for the row you're working on.
Getting the threshold wrong
'10 or more' includes 10; 'more than 10' doesn't. Check the exact words of the rule against the row that sits right on the threshold.
Reading the wrong row, or miscounting
Find the row by its name, not its position, and count rows that meet a rule with ticks, not by eye.
Checking only one of two rules
'Only if both' means a row must pass rule 1 and rule 2. Test each rule on its own and keep only the rows that pass both; a row that passes one is out.
Using one rate for everything
A rate that changes after week 6 applies only from week 7; a percent 'of sales above $40,000' applies only to the part above $40,000; a cap is the most anyone gets. Split the amount at each stated point.
Doing the steps in the wrong order
If the rules take a fee off the refund, work out the refund first and then subtract the fee. Taking it off the price before the percent gives a different number.
Missing the exception, or spreading it
An email or memo can change one rule for one group. Use the new rule for that group, and the old rule for everyone else.
Reading a one-way rule backwards
'Every order over $800 goes to South' says nothing about smaller orders: they can go to South too. Only 'only' or 'never' rules out a place.
Mixing up must, could and cannot
List the places the rules still allow. Must be true: only one is left. Could be true: it's on the list. Cannot be true: it isn't.