GMAT Data Insights lesson · DS: word problems
GMAT Data Sufficiency: word problems
How to judge GMAT Data Sufficiency word problems on totals, ratios, percents, rates and whole-number counts, with worked examples and the classic traps.
The core idea
Turn the story into unknowns and equations, then ask whether the facts pin down the one quantity asked. Two unknowns usually need two independent facts, but a ratio never fixes a count, a percent needs a base, and whole-number counts can make one equation enough.
Core ideas
Words used here
- Unknown: a number the story doesn't tell you, like the number of roses sold.
- Independent facts: facts that can't be worked out from each other. "64 flowers in all" and "18 more roses than tulips" are independent; "a ratio of 3 : 5" and "3/8 of the whole" are not.
- Whole number: 0, 1, 2, 3 and so on. Counts of people or things are whole numbers; prices, times and amounts of water need not be.
Every Data Sufficiency question asks whether the statements give enough information to answer. You never need the answer itself. The five answers never change:
| Answer | Meaning |
|---|---|
| A | Statement (1) alone is sufficient, but statement (2) alone is not. |
| B | Statement (2) alone is sufficient, but statement (1) alone is not. |
| C | Both statements together are sufficient, but neither one alone is. |
| D | Each statement alone is sufficient. |
| E | The two statements together are not sufficient. |
- Model the story first. Name the unknowns (roses r, tulips t) and write the one quantity the question asks for.
- Turn each statement into an equation (r + t = 64) or a condition (r > t).
- Count independent facts. Usually two unknowns need two independent equations. A statement that gives the asked quantity directly is enough by itself.
- Then check the exceptions: whole-number counts can make one equation enough, and a ratio question needs only the ratio, not the counts.
- To show "not sufficient", find two cases that fit the statement and give different answers. To show "sufficient", show that every case gives the same answer.
Why it works. "Sufficient" means one answer, whatever the hidden numbers are. Each independent equation removes one degree of freedom, so two unknowns are pinned down by two of them. A pair of cases that both fit and disagree proves that something is still free.
The AD/BCE method. Judge (1) alone first. If it works, the answer is A or D; if not, it is B, C or E.
Rules the GMAT keeps. The statements are always true and never contradict each other. When you judge (2) alone, forget what (1) said. A definite "no" answers a yes/no question.
Try it. A store sold only red and blue mugs. How many red mugs did it sell? (1) It sold 30 mugs in all. (2) It sold 18 red mugs.
Show the answer
- (1): 20 red with 10 blue and 25 red with 5 blue both fit, with different answers: not sufficient.
- (2): it names the count asked for: 18. Sufficient.
- Answer B. (A statement that names the asked quantity needs no help.)
Counts and totals
Two unknown counts need two independent facts. A total alone or a difference alone leaves many pairs; a total and a difference together fix both counts.
Why it works. A total r + t = 64 is one equation; it allows 40 and 24, 41 and 23, and so on. A difference r − t = 18 is a second, different equation. Adding the two gives 2r = 82, so only one pair fits both.
How to spot it: two groups that make up a whole ("only roses and tulips"), and statements about a total, a difference, a multiple ("three times as many") or one group.
Example. On Saturday a florist sold both roses and tulips, and no other flowers. How many roses did it sell? (1) The florist sold 64 flowers in all. (2) The florist sold 18 more roses than tulips.
- (1): 40 roses with 24 tulips and 41 roses with 23 tulips both fit: not sufficient.
- (2): 20 roses with 2 tulips and 21 roses with 3 tulips both fit: not sufficient.
- Together: r + t = 64 and r − t = 18. Add them: 2r = 82, so r = 41 and t = 23. Sufficient.
- Answer C. Check: 41 + 23 = 64 and 41 − 23 = 18. ✓
Trap: answering E because neither statement gives a count. Two different equations about the same two unknowns are exactly what you need.
Try it. Same florist. Did it sell more roses than tulips? (1) The florist sold 64 flowers in all. (2) The florist sold 18 more roses than tulips.
Show the answer
- (1): 40 roses with 24 tulips gives yes; 20 roses with 44 tulips gives no: not sufficient.
- (2): 18 more roses means more roses in every case, whatever the counts: sufficient (the answer is yes).
- Answer B. You don't need the counts to answer a comparison.
Check yourself. How many tulips did the florist sell? (1) The florist sold 23 tulips. (2) The florist sold 64 flowers in all.
Check your answer
(1) names the count: sufficient. (2) leaves 40 roses with 24 tulips or 41 with 23: not sufficient. A.
Ratios and parts
A ratio fixes the shares, never a count. Add one real number (a total, a difference or one count) and every count follows. A fraction of the whole is the same fact as the ratio, said another way.
Why it works. Altos : sopranos = 3 : 5 means the choir is made of equal "parts", 3 of altos and 5 of sopranos, but the size of a part is free. One amount fixes the size of a part, and then everything is known.
How to spot it: "the ratio of A to B", "A makes up 3/8 of", "40% of the members are", or "if 6 more joined, the ratio would be".
Example. A choir has only altos and sopranos. How many altos are in the choir? (1) The ratio of altos to sopranos is 3 : 5. (2) The choir has 48 members.
- (1): 3 altos with 5 sopranos and 6 altos with 10 sopranos both fit: not sufficient.
- (2): 1 alto with 47 sopranos and 2 altos with 46 sopranos both fit: not sufficient.
- Together: 3 + 5 = 8 parts make 48 members, so one part is 48 ÷ 8 = 6, and the altos are 3 × 6 = 18. Sufficient.
- Answer C.
Trap: replacing (2) with "sopranos make up 5/8 of the choir" and answering C. It is the 3 : 5 ratio again, so together the statements still allow 18 and 30 or 9 and 15: E.
Try it. What fraction of the choir are altos? (1) The ratio of altos to sopranos is 3 : 5. (2) There are 12 more sopranos than altos.
Show the answer
- (1): 3 parts of 8 are altos in every choir that fits, so the fraction is 3/8: sufficient.
- (2): 1 alto with 13 sopranos gives 1/14; 2 altos with 14 sopranos gives 2/16 = 1/8: not sufficient.
- Answer A. A question about a fraction or ratio needs only the ratio.
Check yourself. How many sopranos are in the choir? (1) If 6 more altos joined, there would be as many altos as sopranos. (2) The ratio of altos to sopranos is 3 : 5.
Check your answer
(1) alone says s = a + 6 (many pairs); (2) alone is a ratio. Together: 5 parts − 3 parts = 2 parts = 6, so a part is 3 and there are 5 × 3 = 15 sopranos (9 altos; 9 + 6 = 15 ✓). C.
Percents and percent change
A percent is a fraction of a base. A percent alone gives a relationship, not an amount; one dollar amount turns it into numbers. A percent change needs the original value as well as the change, but a question about the percent itself can be answered from a percent statement alone.
Why it works. "Up 25%" means new = 1.25 × old: true for $40 → $50 and for $48 → $60. It fixes the ratio new ÷ old, which is all a percent question asks, but no dollar amount. A dollar change ($12) with no base can be a big or a small percent.
How to spot it: "went up by 20%", "is 120% of", "spent 15% of the budget", "the rest was $170,000".
Example. The price of a lamp went up this year. By what percent did it go up? (1) The price went up by $12. (2) The new price is $60.
- (1): $40 → $52 is a 30% rise; $60 → $72 is a 20% rise: not sufficient.
- (2): $50 → $60 is 20%; $40 → $60 is 50%: not sufficient.
- Together: the old price is 60 − 12 = $48, and 12 ÷ 48 = 1/4 = 25%. Sufficient.
- Answer C.
Trap: dividing by the new price, 12 ÷ 60 = 20%. The base of a percent change is the original value.
Try it. What was the price of the lamp before the change? (1) The price went up by 25%. (2) The new price is 125% of the old price.
Show the answer
- (1): $48 → $60 and $40 → $50 both fit: not sufficient.
- (2): it is the same fact (× 1.25), with the same two cases: not sufficient.
- Together: still the same one fact. E.
Edge cases.
- Two changes in a row multiply. If sales rose 25% in the first year and 50% over both years, the second year's change is 1.5 ÷ 1.25 = 1.2, a 20% rise, with no sales figure at all.
- Part and rest. "15% went to laptops" and "$170,000 was left" combine: the rest is 85%, so the budget is 170,000 ÷ 0.85 = $200,000.
Check yourself. A school spent part of its budget on laptops. How much did it spend on laptops? (1) It spent 15% of the budget on laptops. (2) After paying for laptops, it had $170,000 of the budget left.
Check your answer
Each alone leaves the budget free. Together: 85% of the budget is $170,000, so the budget is $200,000 and the laptops cost 15% of it, $30,000 (200,000 − 170,000 = 30,000 ✓). C.
Rates and work
Work with rates (jobs per hour), not times: rates add when machines work together. A combined time needs both rates, or their sum. Distance = speed × time, so a distance needs two of the three, and a statement can hide one of them.
Why it works. A pump that drains a tank in 6 hours drains 1/6 of it each hour. Two pumps working together drain the sum of their rates each hour; times never add. For trips, each statement fixes speed, time, distance or a product of them, and two independent facts fix the third.
How to spot it: "alone in 6 hours", "together in 4 hours", "twice as fast", "at a constant speed", "the same trip at 60 miles per hour would take".
Example. Pumps A and B each drain a tank at a constant rate. How many hours would pump B take to drain the tank alone? (1) Pump A alone drains the tank in 6 hours. (2) Working together, the two pumps drain it in 4 hours.
- (1): says nothing about B: not sufficient.
- (2): A in 6 hours with B in 12, and A in 8 hours with B in 8, both give 4 hours together: not sufficient.
- Together: B's rate is 1/4 − 1/6 = 3/12 − 2/12 = 1/12 of the tank per hour, so B takes 12 hours. Sufficient.
- Answer C.
Trap: subtracting times (6 − 4 = 2 hours for B). Times don't add or subtract; rates do.
Try it. Ravi drove to a lake at a constant speed. How far did he drive? (1) His speed was 48 miles per hour. (2) The same drive would have taken 2 hours at a speed of 60 miles per hour.
Show the answer
- (1): 48 miles per hour for 2 hours (96 miles) and for 3 hours (144 miles) both fit: not sufficient.
- (2): the distance is 60 × 2 = 120 miles, whatever Ravi's own speed: sufficient.
- Answer B. A statement about another speed can still give the distance.
Check yourself. An empty 600-liter tank has an inlet pipe and an outlet pipe. With both open, how many minutes does it take to fill? (1) The inlet pipe moves 15 more liters per minute than the outlet pipe. (2) The inlet pipe alone fills the tank in 24 minutes.
Check your answer
(1): the tank gains 15 liters a minute, so it fills in 600 ÷ 15 = 40 minutes: sufficient. (2): the inlet moves 600 ÷ 24 = 25 liters a minute, but the outlet is unknown: not sufficient. A.
Whole-number constraints
Counts are whole numbers, so one equation can be enough. Before you say "two unknowns need two equations", list the whole-number solutions. If two are left, look for a fact that rules one out.
Why it works. Over all numbers, 7a + 4c = 37 is a line with endless points. Counts must be whole numbers of at least 1, and only a few points on that line qualify: often one, sometimes two or three. A short list is a complete search.
How to spot it: two prices, weights or sizes and a total ("adult tickets cost $7 and child tickets $4; the group spent $37"), with counts that must be whole numbers.
Example. At a museum, adult tickets cost $7 each and child tickets cost $4 each. A group bought adult and child tickets, at least one of each. How many adult tickets did it buy? (1) The group spent $37. (2) The group bought 7 tickets.
- (1): 7a + 4c = 37. Try a = 1 to 5 and check whether 37 − 7a is a multiple of 4: 30, 23, 16, 9, 2. Only a = 3 works, with c = 4. Sufficient.
- (2): 1 adult with 6 children and 2 adults with 5 children both fit: not sufficient.
- Answer A.
Trap: the same question with a total of $47. Then 47 − 7a is 40, 33, 26, 19, 12: a = 1 (10 children) and a = 5 (3 children) both work, so the total alone is not sufficient. Add "the group bought more adult tickets than child tickets" and only 5 and 3 is left: answer C.
Try it. Pens cost $3 each and notebooks $5 each. Lee spent $31 on pens and notebooks, at least one of each. How many pens did Lee buy? (1) Lee bought an odd number of notebooks. (2) Lee bought more than 3 pens.
Show the answer
- List the solutions of 3p + 5n = 31: n = 2 gives p = 7, and n = 5 gives p = 2 (n = 1, 3, 4 leave 26, 16, 11, not multiples of 3).
- (1): odd n leaves only n = 5, p = 2: sufficient.
- (2): more than 3 pens leaves only p = 7: sufficient.
- Answer D.
Check yourself. Muffins cost $2 each and pies $9 each. A caterer spent $40 on muffins and pies, at least one of each. How many pies? (1) The caterer bought fewer than 10 items. (2) The caterer bought an even number of pies.
Check your answer
2m + 9p = 40 needs p even: p = 2 (m = 11, 13 items) or p = 4 (m = 2, 6 items). (1) keeps only 4 pies: sufficient. (2) keeps both: not sufficient. A.
Practice
Work through Data Sufficiency word problems on the practice page.
Common traps
Trusting a ratio, a percent or a difference without an amount
A ratio of 3 : 5 fits 3 and 5, 6 and 10, 30 and 50. Before you call a statement sufficient, find two cases that fit it and answer differently: if you can, it isn't enough.
Combining two statements that say the same thing
'The ratio of altos to sopranos is 3 : 5' and 'sopranos are 5/8 of the choir' are one fact said two ways. Together they still leave many choirs, so the answer is E, not C.
Assuming two unknowns always need two equations
When the unknowns are whole numbers, one equation can have only one solution: 7a + 4c = 37 forces a = 3, c = 4. A statement can also settle a yes/no question with a definite no, or hide a whole amount (the same trip at another speed gives the distance).
Stopping after the first sufficient statement
Judge each statement on its own, every time. If (1) alone works, (2) alone might work too (answer D), and you never need both (C is out).
Not combining when neither statement works alone
A total and a difference, a ratio and a total, a percent and one dollar amount: each half is useless alone, but together they give two independent equations. Write both down before you pick E.