Hard GMAT Data Sufficiency Questions (with Explanations)

The hardest GMAT Data Sufficiency practice questions, with worked solutions: what makes Data Sufficiency hard, the hidden traps at the top level, and how to test statements properly.

By the Relvora team · Updated · 3 min read

At the top difficulty level, Data Sufficiency stops being about algebra and becomes about doubt: knowing when a statement only seems to settle the question. Below are five of the hardest Data Sufficiency questions in Relvora's Data Insights bank, with worked solutions.

In short: Hard Data Sufficiency questions use two tricks. Statements can look insufficient but fix exactly what's asked, for example a combination of two unknowns. Or they can look sufficient while an unstated case gives a second answer. Test every statement with two different examples, including negatives, fractions and zero.

The two ways hard Data Sufficiency fools you

1. It looks insufficient, but it's enough. A statement with two unknowns can still fix the value of the expression the question asks about. "What is x + 2y?" needs only x + 2y, not x and y. Rephrase the question before you read the statements.

2. It looks sufficient, but it isn't. You find one value that fits and stop. A second value, often negative, fractional or zero, fits too and gives a different answer. At Level 5, the second case is usually one that's easy to forget.

A checklist for the hardest questions

  • Rephrase first. What exactly would be enough? A value, a sign, a yes or no?
  • Two examples, not one. For each statement, find two different cases that fit it. Same answer both times means it's probably sufficient. Different answers prove it isn't.
  • Question the constraints. Integers? Positive? Distinct? Only if the question says so.
  • Combining can still fail. Two statements can overlap so that together they add nothing new.

Five hard Data Sufficiency questions

These are Levels 4 and 5 of 5. Use the checklist, and give yourself about two minutes each.

  1. Question 1 · Data Sufficiency: word problems · Level 4 of 5 · Data Sufficiency · about 3 min

    A courier drove from a depot to a warehouse at a constant speed. How far did the courier travel? (1) The delivery run was 110 miles long. (2) The delivery run would have taken 2 hours 45 minutes at a speed of 40 miles per hour.

    1. (A)Statement (1) alone is sufficient, but statement (2) alone is not.
    2. (B)Statement (2) alone is sufficient, but statement (1) alone is not.
    3. (C)Both statements together are sufficient, but neither one alone is.
    4. (D)Each statement alone is sufficient.
    5. (E)The two statements together are not sufficient.
    Show the answer and explanation

    Answer: (D) Each statement alone is sufficient.

    (1) alone: The amounts can vary (20 miles per hour for 5 hours 30 minutes, or 24 miles per hour for 4 hours 35 minutes), but every case that fits gives 110 miles. (2) alone: 40 miles per hour for 2 hours 45 minutes covers 110 miles, so the delivery run was 110 miles long. The amounts can vary (20 miles per hour for 5 hours 30 minutes, or 24 miles per hour for 4 hours 35 minutes), but every case that fits gives 110 miles. Answer: D.

    Why the wrong answers tempt people

    • (A) Statement (2) alone is enough. 40 miles per hour for 2 hours 45 minutes covers 110 miles, so the delivery run was 110 miles long. The amounts can vary (20 miles per hour for 5 hours 30 minutes, or 24 miles per hour for 4 hours 35 minutes), but every case that fits gives 110 miles.
    • (B) Statement (1) alone is enough. The amounts can vary (20 miles per hour for 5 hours 30 minutes, or 24 miles per hour for 4 hours 35 minutes), but every case that fits gives 110 miles.
    • (C) You don't need both: statement (1) alone is enough. The amounts can vary (20 miles per hour for 5 hours 30 minutes, or 24 miles per hour for 4 hours 35 minutes), but every case that fits gives 110 miles.
  2. Question 2 · Data Sufficiency: inequalities and comparisons · Level 5 of 5 · Data Sufficiency · about 3 min

    If x and y are nonzero real numbers, is x/y > 0? (1) x/y < 0. (2) xy < 0.

    1. (A)Statement (1) alone is sufficient, but statement (2) alone is not.
    2. (B)Statement (2) alone is sufficient, but statement (1) alone is not.
    3. (C)Both statements together are sufficient, but neither one alone is.
    4. (D)Each statement alone is sufficient.
    5. (E)The two statements together are not sufficient.
    Show the answer and explanation

    Answer: (D) Each statement alone is sufficient.

    (1) alone: x/y < 0 means x and y have opposite signs. Every such pair makes x/y > 0 false, so the answer is a definite no. (2) alone: xy < 0 means x and y have opposite signs. Every such pair makes x/y > 0 false, so the answer is a definite no. Answer: D.

    Why the wrong answers tempt people

    • (A) Statement (2) alone is enough. xy < 0 means x and y have opposite signs. Every such pair makes x/y > 0 false, so the answer is a definite no.
    • (B) Statement (1) alone is enough. x/y < 0 means x and y have opposite signs. Every such pair makes x/y > 0 false, so the answer is a definite no.
    • (C) You don't need both: statement (1) alone is enough. x/y < 0 means x and y have opposite signs. Every such pair makes x/y > 0 false, so the answer is a definite no.
  3. Question 3 · Data Sufficiency: word problems · Level 5 of 5 · Data Sufficiency · about 3 min

    At a supply store, pens cost $6 each and notebooks cost $4 each. Lee spent $82 on pens and notebooks, at least one of each. How many notebooks did Lee buy? (1) Lee bought at most 6 notebooks. (2) Lee bought an odd number of pens.

    1. (A)Statement (1) alone is sufficient, but statement (2) alone is not.
    2. (B)Statement (2) alone is sufficient, but statement (1) alone is not.
    3. (C)Both statements together are sufficient, but neither one alone is.
    4. (D)Each statement alone is sufficient.
    5. (E)The two statements together are not sufficient.
    Show the answer and explanation

    Answer: (E) The two statements together are not sufficient.

    (1) alone: Both 11 pens with 4 notebooks and 13 pens with 1 notebook fit, but they give 4 and 1. (2) alone: Both 11 pens with 4 notebooks and 9 pens with 7 notebooks fit, but they give 4 and 7. Together: Both 11 pens with 4 notebooks and 13 pens with 1 notebook fit, but they give 4 and 1. Answer: E.

    Why the wrong answers tempt people

    • (A) Statement (1) alone isn't enough. Both 11 pens with 4 notebooks and 13 pens with 1 notebook fit, but they give 4 and 1.
    • (B) Statement (2) alone isn't enough. Both 11 pens with 4 notebooks and 9 pens with 7 notebooks fit, but they give 4 and 7.
    • (C) Even together the statements aren't enough. Both 11 pens with 4 notebooks and 13 pens with 1 notebook fit, but they give 4 and 1.
  4. Question 4 · Data Sufficiency: statistics and sets · Level 5 of 5 · Data Sufficiency · about 3 min

    A list consists of five different positive integers, each less than 15. If the number 4 were added to the list, would the average (arithmetic mean) increase? (1) Removing the greatest number from the list would leave numbers with an average (arithmetic mean) of 3.5. (2) The range of the numbers is 4.

    1. (A)Statement (1) alone is sufficient, but statement (2) alone is not.
    2. (B)Statement (2) alone is sufficient, but statement (1) alone is not.
    3. (C)Both statements together are sufficient, but neither one alone is.
    4. (D)Each statement alone is sufficient.
    5. (E)The two statements together are not sufficient.
    Show the answer and explanation

    Answer: (A) Statement (1) alone is sufficient, but statement (2) alone is not.

    (1) alone: it means the four smaller numbers add up to 3.5 × 4 = 14. In every list that fits, the answer is no: the average is always from 4 to 5.6, never less than 4, so adding 4 can't raise it. For example, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 (average 4) and 2, 3, 4, 5, 7 (average 4.2). (2) alone: Both 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 (average 4) and 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 (average 3) fit, so the answer could be yes or no. Answer: A.

    Why the wrong answers tempt people

    • (B) Statement (2) alone isn't enough. Both 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 (average 4) and 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 (average 3) fit, so the answer could be yes or no.
    • (C) You don't need both: statement (1) alone is enough. It means the four smaller numbers add up to 3.5 × 4 = 14. In every list that fits, the answer is no: the average is always from 4 to 5.6, never less than 4, so adding 4 can't raise it. For example, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 (average 4) and 2, 3, 4, 5, 7 (average 4.2).
    • (E) Statement (1) alone is enough. It means the four smaller numbers add up to 3.5 × 4 = 14. In every list that fits, the answer is no: the average is always from 4 to 5.6, never less than 4, so adding 4 can't raise it. For example, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 (average 4) and 2, 3, 4, 5, 7 (average 4.2).
  5. Question 5 · Data Sufficiency: number properties · Level 5 of 5 · Data Sufficiency · about 3 min

    If x and y are nonzero integers, is x + y > 0? (1) x > 0. (2) x + y < 0.

    1. (A)Statement (1) alone is sufficient, but statement (2) alone is not.
    2. (B)Statement (2) alone is sufficient, but statement (1) alone is not.
    3. (C)Both statements together are sufficient, but neither one alone is.
    4. (D)Each statement alone is sufficient.
    5. (E)The two statements together are not sufficient.
    Show the answer and explanation

    Answer: (B) Statement (2) alone is sufficient, but statement (1) alone is not.

    (1) alone: Both x = 1, y = −1 and x = 1, y = 1 fit, but they give no and yes. (2) alone: The cases that fit it are x = −1, y = −1; x = −2, y = −1; x = −2, y = 1 and so on, and every one gives the answer no. Answer: B.

    Why the wrong answers tempt people

    • (A) Statement (1) alone isn't enough. Both x = 1, y = −1 and x = 1, y = 1 fit, but they give no and yes.
    • (C) You don't need both: statement (2) alone is enough. The cases that fit it are x = −1, y = −1; x = −2, y = −1; x = −2, y = 1 and so on, and every one gives the answer no.
    • (E) Statement (2) alone is enough. The cases that fit it are x = −1, y = −1; x = −2, y = −1; x = −2, y = 1 and so on, and every one gives the answer no.

Practice at the right level

Hard questions help most once medium ones are reliable. Relvora's Data Insights track moves you up a level on a skill only when your earlier levels hold, and it mixes Data Sufficiency with the four other Data Insights types as the real section does. Take the free Data Insights diagnostic to see where you stand. For the basic method, see GMAT Data Sufficiency practice questions.

GMAT™ is a trademark of GMAC. Relvora is not affiliated with or endorsed by GMAC.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

What makes a GMAT Data Sufficiency question hard?

Hard Data Sufficiency questions look sufficient when they aren't, or insufficient when they are. A statement may seem to leave two unknowns but fix the combination the question asks for, or seem to give one value while an unstated case (a negative, a fraction, zero) gives another.

How do you avoid traps in hard Data Sufficiency questions?

Test with two different numbers that both fit the statement, including negatives, fractions and zero unless the question rules them out. If they give different answers, the statement isn't sufficient.

How long should a hard Data Sufficiency question take?

Data Insights averages 2 minutes 15 seconds per question, and Data Sufficiency often takes less because there's no table to read. Spend the saved time on the multi-source and table questions.

More GMAT Data Insights practice

GMAT™ is a trademark of GMAC. GRE® is a registered trademark of ETS. SAT® is a registered trademark of the College Board. Relvora is not affiliated with or endorsed by any of them. The sample questions are Relvora's own, written to the published format.